Title header



 

 


Works created 1834-1866 sometimes described as English Operas

Various authors, e.g. Allardyce Nicoll [1], George Biddlecombe [2] and the Stanford University Opera Premieres website [3], named a number of works as English language operas that have not been included in the English opera list. This was because they were not seen or described as such at the time or, in a few cases, the evidence is so slight that it was not possible to be sure what they were.

Some confusion often arose because, in London before 1843, only Drury Lane, Covent Garden and, in the summer, the Haymarket, could offer spoken drama. To circumvent these rules, other theatres included songs or other music in their drama thus sometimes blurring the boundary between them and what was considered and advertised as English Opera. This practice lingered on even when the legal necessity had disappeared. Such works went under the titles of operettas, burlesques, burlettas and, later, musicals and often drew on existing, rather than original, music. English opera was usually distinguished by some level of dramatic intent and a greater amount, originality and complexity of music. Its performers were known primarily as singers rather than as actors.

Another category that has not been included in the list of English operas are the direct English translations of continental operas, including Balfe's French operas. There is a distinction between them and cases where the librettist used a continental opera as a starting point but adapted it to fit the presumed English differences in taste, particularly adding a happy ending. The composer then used that new libretto as the basis for an original English opera.

Towards the end of the period there was a move to shorter works with flimsy and often comic plots that went under different descriptions, such as operettas, comic opera, opera di camera and musicals, and showed a definite break from English opera. This movement is discussed below. 

[1] Allardyce Nicoll, A History of English Drama. 1660-1900, Volume IV (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970),

[2] George Biddlecombe. English opera from 1834 to 1864 with particular reference to the works of Michael Balfe. (New York: Garland Publishing, 1994)

[3] Stanford University Opera Premieres website, available at https://exhibits.stanford.edu/operadata [accessed Jan. 2, 2022]

 

1834

The Dragon

George Alexander Lee / Thomas Morton (?), English Opera House, August 4, 1834

Described as a one act comic operetta but The Standard (August 5, 1834) states that it would be more correct to call it "a short farce with a few songs introduced". Lee contributed the songs with the main text by Morton. Nicoll [1] states that this refers to John Maddison Morton (1811 - 1891) but the Morning Post (August 5, 1834) calls him "the veteran Morton", suggesting that it is more likely to be his father Thomas (1764-1838). It was introduced as an afterpiece to a performance of Nourjahad.

The Widow Queen

Edward Loder / Thomas Serle, English Opera House, August 9, 1834

This was a drama by Serle for which Loder wrote an overture and some songs.

Genevieve or The Maid of Switzerland

George Alexander Macfarren / Mrs Cornwell Baron-Wilson, English Opera House, November 3, 1834

This operetta by Baron-Wilson was introduced as a one act curtain raiser to Hermann or The Broken Spear. According to the Morning Post (November 4, 1834), it was a translation of a French work and variants of it seemed to have been staged in earlier years. Macfarren was said to have contributed an overture, a song and choruses.

The Red Mask or The Council of Three

Tom Cooke - Marco Aurelio Marliani / James R. Planché, Drury Lane, November 15, 1834

This was an English version with words by Planché and adapted by Tom Cooke of Marliani's opera, Il bravo, given in Paris earlier in the year.

[1] Allardyce Nicoll. A History of English Drama. 1660-1900, Volume IV. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970), p.361

 

1835

The Shadow on the Wall

John Thomson / Thomas Serle, English Opera House, April 20, 1835

This was a drama by Serle with music by Thomson, composer of Hermann.  It is sometimes claimed as Thomson's second opera but it was advertised as an afterpiece to Sadak and Kalasrade and its main actor was Serle (not a singer). Thomson in a letter to the Musical World cited Hermann as his only opera [1].

[1] "Correspondence", The Musical World, Volume 14 (July 2, 1840), p.9

I and My Double

George Alexander Macfarren / John Oxenford, English Opera House, June 10, 1835

This was a farce by Oxenford  for which Macfarren wrote some music.

The Dice of Death

Edward Loder / John Oxenford, English Opera House, September 14, 1835

This was a titled a romantic drama.  It was by Oxenford  for which Loder wrote some music.

Love in a Cottage

George Alexander Lee / Thomas Haynes Bayly, The Olympic, September 28, 1835

This was a burletta by Bayly with songs by Lee. No reference to a performance at the  Strand Theatre in 1839 has been found as listed in the Stanford University Opera Premieres page

Paul Clifford

George Rodwell - Jonathan Blewitt / Edward Fitzball - Edward Lytton Bulwer, Covent Garden, October 28, 1835

Advertised as a drama or musical drama, this was an adaptation by Fitzball of Lytton Bulwer's novel. Although the music was sometimes attributed solely to Rodwell, who provided "some pretty ballads", several sources also include Blewitt [1]. The novelty of including a coach drawn onto the stage by four horses seems to have been quite a sensation. 

[1] Morning Post (Oct. 29, 1835).

 

1836

Quasimodo, or The Gipsy Girl of Notre Dame

George Rodwell (Carl Maria von Weber) / Edward Fitzball,  Covent Garden, February 2, 1836

Described as an operatic drama based on Victor Hugo's novel with the music arranged by Rodwell from various works of Weber. The words of the songs can  be found here.

Innocent Sins

George Alexander  Macfarren / George  Macfarren,  New Strand Theatre, August 15, 1836

A musical burletta by George Macfarren with music by his son, George Alexander Macfarren.  The Naval and Military Gazette (Aug. 20, 1836) said it possessed "the sin of being innocent of everything necessary to constitute a burletta" and it was soon withdrawn. The News (London) (Aug. 21, 1836) claimed that it was a renaming of a piece called Peccadilloes, which had been first given on April 21, 1831 at the Queen's Theatre, whose management George Macfarren had taken on in the previous February.

The Gaberlunzie Man

William Rede (?) / William Rede, English Opera House, September 26, 1836

Advertised as a Scottish operatic drama by Rede (It is not clear if he also wrote or arranged the music). The Spectator (October 1, 1836) called it a musical afterpiece "serving ... to introduce several Scottish airs and romantic adventures, and to show off (John) Wilson in a picturesque dress".

 

1837

King of the Danube

Auguste Pilate / John Buckstone, Adelphi, March 27, 1837

This was described as a ballet - burletta stemming from Adam/Taglioni's La Fille du Danube produced at the Paris Opéra in 1836. The text was adapted by Buckstone and most of the music composed by Pilati, but a few items were taken from Adam, Bellini and others [1].

[1] Adelphi Theatre Project website, available at  https://www.umass.edu/AdelphiTheatreCalendar/m36d.htm [accessed Jan. 2, 2022).

Rory O'More

Jonathan Blewitt / Samuel Lover, Adelphi, September 29, 1837

This was a burletta written by Lover based on his popular novel published earlier in the year. Blewitt provided the music [1]. Lover [2] claimed that it ran for 108 nights at the Adelphi in its first season.

[1] Stanley Sadie (ed.), Grove Dictionary of Opera. Vol 1 (London: Macmillan, 1992), Vol. 1, p. 500.

[2] Samuel Lover (ed.), The Lyrics of Ireland  (London: Houlston and Wright, 1858)

The Afrancesado or Secrecy and Truth

George Alexander Lee / Thomas James Serle, Covent Garden, October 19, 1837

This was a "melodramatic romance" (Morning Post,  Oct. 20, 1837) by Serle with music by Lee.

 

1838

The Outpost

John Hullah / Thomas James Serle, Covent Garden, May 17, 1838

Described both on the manuscript submitted to the Examiner of Plays and in the press as a one act operetta. The Standard (May 18, 1838) called it "An amusing little operetta of no great pretensions". It did note that "the music was of a popular character".

The Harvest Queen

Henry Phillips / Henry Phillips, Drury Lane, May 22, 1838

Phillips wrote both music and words as well as singing in it for his benefit night. It was widely deemed a failure and never repeated. Actors by Gaslight (June 2, 1838), p. 53, wrote that " Of the composition, as a whole, we can safely say it is miserable; no plot, no melody (except it be pilfered), no harmony, no dialogue (except it be worse than naught)".  The Morning Post (May 22, 1838) described it as a "petit opera" and other newspapers called it an opera but it was a slight one act piece [1], an "agreeable trifle"[2], that was staged ahead of Benedict's The Gipsy's Warning. The manuscript [3] sent to the Examiner, Charles Kemble, described it as an operetta. 

[1] On ff 334, the manuscript has "End of Act 1", but, in fact, the work was just divided into 3 scenes.

poster

[2] The Morning Chronicle (May 23, 1838) was more positive than other newspapers but even it thought that "its materials are by no means of a durable kind".

[3] British Library, Add MS 42956, ff 328 - 340.

The Foresters or twenty five years since

Thomas James Serle / Edward Loder, Covent Garden, October 19, 1838

This was a drama by Serle, although The Era (October 21, 1838) reported that he was said to have disclaimed it. Loder wrote an overture and some songs.  The Times (October 20, 1838) reported that the spirited overture was unanimously encored but that the "'interspersed airs, although pleasing, made no great no impression, and gave no great relief to the whole".

 

1839

Agnes Bernauer, the Maid of Augsburg

George Alexander Macfarren / Thomas James Serle, Covent Garden, April 20, 1839
  
This was described as a romantic melodrama. It was written by Serle and had incidental music by  Macfarren.

The Pupil of Da Vinci

Joseph Augustine Wade / Mark Lemon, St James's Theatre, November 29, 1839

The Champion (Dec. 8, 1839) described it as "a pretty little operetta". The "smoothly written" libretto was by Lemon and the music by Wade, whose melodies were "distinguished by graceful simplicity". It was said to have been eminently successful.

 

1840

Lundy in the Olden Times

Cornelius Bryan / Miss  Bryan (Ann Bryan?)

Mentioned in George Biddlecombe's English opera from 1834 to 1864 with particular reference to the works of Michael Balfe. (New York: Garland Publishing, 1994), p.333 as composed by Bryan to a text by Miss Bryan, who was probably his sister, Ann. However, the Bristol Times (Mar. 21, 1840) reported that during a break in rehearsals on Wednesday, March 18, Bryan had been walking around the darkened stage, fell down through an open trapdoor and died of his injuries the following day. The opera had been intended to premiere on March 24 but was postponed. It was given on March 27, 1840 as a benefit for Miss Bryan but that appeared to be its only performance. Bryan had been organist of St. Mary, Redcliff in Bristol. Although a licence was issued (Add MS 71564), no manuscript seemed to have been received  by the Examiner of Plays (Add MS 53702).

Although the poster referred to it as an opera, James Love's Scottish Church Music (William Blackwood and Sons: Edinburgh and London, 1891), p. 86, called it as an operetta, probably more likely although no evidence was given.

poster

Poster - David Chandler, "Before Ethel", Opera (May, 2022), p.550

Hedwig von Linden

Prince Albert / ?

Around the time of the marriage of Prince Albert to Queen Victoria on February 10, 1840, there were reports that an opera by Prince Albert was to be produced at Drury Lane. The Court Circular for February 19, 1840, eventually denied  this. However, the publisher and bookseller John Limbird wrote to The Times (Feb. 20, 1840) claiming that he had many compositions by Prince Albert in his possession and that "these have been placed in the hands of a well-known musician, who is now moulding them into a dramatic form, and wedding them to a libretto by a popular author".  The Allgemeine Theaterzeitung (Aug. 17, 1840) reported that Prince Albert's Hedwig von Linden was in preparation in London. Whether these two mentions refer to the same opera or not, no performances were staged of any operas by Prince Albert or using his music in some way. The Musical World  (Nov. 26, 1840), p. 347, in a satirical poem about Albert's musical talents wrote "His highness write an opera! flam and flash!". Nicholas Temperley,  "The Prince Consort, Champion of Music" Musical Times (Dec., 1961), pp. 762-764, considers Albert's broader musical impact.

Triboulet or The King's Jester
( or The King's Fool or The Old Man's Curse)

Isaac Nathan / John Gideon Millingen, Sadler's Wells, 1840

The Stanford University Opera Premieres site claims that this was an opera first staged at Sadler's Wells in 1840. In fact, it had first been performed at the Victoria Theatre on July 17, 1833. It was an English version by Millingen of Victor Hugo's Le Roi s'amuse and described as a drama with music by Nathan, of which "we can say nothing flattering", Sun (July 18, 1833). 

The Greek Boy

Samuel Lover [1] / Samuel Lover, Covent Garden, September 29, 1840

This was described as a musical drama. It was an afterpiece to the main work and designed as a vehicle for Lucy Vestris, the Covent Garden manager.

[1] A short biography of Lover by Martin Walton can be found in the Dublin Historical Record , Mar., 1979, Vol. 32, No. 2 (Mar., 1979), pp. 57-66 (available at http://www.jstor.com/stable/30104305 )

 

1841

The Deer Stalkers

Edward Loder / Mark Lemon, English Opera House, April 12, 1841

This was first performed as an afterpiece to Balfe's opera Keolanthe and, according to The Stage (August 24, 1841) was basically a vehicle for a number of Scottish ballads sung by John Wilson and some characteristic highland comedy from Mr M'Ian, the whole thing adding up to a stereotypical Scottish sketch that had become all too common. Loder arranged the music, of which, "it would be gross flattery to say anything in commendation". The text was by Lemon.  It is sometimes labelled a Scottish opera.

Arcadia, or, The Shepherd and the Shepherdess

J. (?) Harroway / Edward Lytton Blanchard, Olympic Temple, April 19, 1841.

Described by The Era (September 25, 1841) as a "grand mythological spectacle".  It was put on at the Olympic Temple because the Royal Grecian Saloon was undergoing extensive alterations. The text was by Blanchard and the music by Harroway[1]

[1] George Biddlecombe. English opera from 1834 to 1864 with particular reference to the works of Michael Balfe. (New York: Garland Publishing, 1994), p.334. The Champion (August 11, 1839) refers to symphonies and accompaniment by J. Harroway.

Il Paddy Whack in Italia

Samuel Lover / Samuel Lover, English Opera House, April 22, 1841.

Although referred to as an opera in the Morning Post (August 21, 1841), the score describes it as an Operetta in one act. The text and the music was by Samuel Lover but possibly with help from Balfe[1].

[1] Basil Walsh.Michael W. Balfe. (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 2008), p. 83, states the composer as Glover but this seems a confusion with Lover. A short biography of Lover by Martin Walton can be found in the Dublin Historical Record , Mar., 1979, Vol. 32, No. 2 (Mar., 1979), pp. 57-66 (available at http://www.jstor.com/stable/30104305 )

 

1842

The Students of Bonn

George Rodwell / William Bayle Bernard (?), Drury Lane, March 21, 1842.

Described in The Spectator (Apr. 2, 1842) as a "light operetta in one act". It claimed it was a musical version of a play called Boarding-School with the "pretty" music by Rodwell. A play called The Boarding School  by W.B. Bernard had premiered at the Haymarket on September 2, 1841.

The Follies of a Night

Tom Cooke / James R. Planché, Drury Lane, October 5, 1842.

This was described as a vaudeville comedy adapted by Planché from a French comedy entitled Charlot. Planché in a preface to the libretto mentioned that some songs were adapted by Cooke.  It starred Charles Matthews and Lucy Vestris and was "perfectly successful" (The Standard, Oct. 6, 1842).  The piece reappeared many times over the next 30 years and around 1876, Planché revised the text and Virginia Gilbert set it to music[1]. However, Gilbert died in an accident before its production [2]. There is a libretto in the Library of Congress and a vocal score here, which the British Library provisionally dated as 1860, which would seem too early.

[1] Morning Post (Feb. 16, 1876)

[2] Wakefield Herald (Aug. 18, 1877)

  

1843

The Queen of the Thames

John Liptrot Hatton / Edward Fitzball, Drury Lane, February 25, 1843.

A one act operetta that played second on the bill. The text was by Fitzball and the music by Hatton was described as " very common-place, but at the same time was pleasing" by The Standard (February 27, 1843).

Geraldine, or, The Lover's Well

Michael William Balfe / Gilbert à Beckett - George Soane, Princess's Theatre, August 14, 1843

This was an English version of Balfe's Le puits d'amour that had been premiered at the Opéra Comique in Paris. Biddlecombe [1] cites Gilbert à Beckett as translator but the Morning Post (Aug. 15, 1843) names George Soane as does Blackwood's Lady's Magazine. (September, 1843), p.184, with its remarks about Soane's  "mass of clumsy and vapid dialogue".

[1] George Biddlecombe. English opera from 1834 to 1864 with particular reference to the works of Michael Balfe. (New York: Garland Publishing, 1994), p.334 .

 

1844

The Castle of Aymon, or, The Four Feathers

Michael William Balfe / Gilbert à Beckett - Thomas H. Reynoldson, Princess's Theatre, November 20, 1844

This was an English version of Balfe's Les quatre fils Aymon that had been premiered at the Opéra Comique in Paris.  Biddlecombe [1] cites Beckett as translator. However, the manuscript in the British Library (Add MS 42979,  ff. 677-694) names Thomas H. Reynoldson. Beckett was the author of a "new extravaganza" called Joe Miller and his Men that was introduced around a month later and followed the opera (Star of Freedom, Dec. 28, 1844), which might be the source of the confusion.  See here for the opera libretto. Henry Chorley considered it Balfe's best opera [2]

[1] George Biddlecombe. Op.Cit., p.334.

[2]  Henry F. Chorley,   Thirty Years' Musical Recollections. Vol. 2 (London: Hurst and Blackett, 1862)   p.136

 

1845

Adventures in America

Henry Phillipsl / Henry Phillips - Martin Tupper,  Northampton, August 11, 1845 (?) [1].

This was a lecture/ song recital resulting from Phillips's recent trip to America.  He toured the provinces with it during autumn 1845 and spring 1846, accompanying himself on the piano. As well as songs he had learned on his travels, there was some original material by Phillips with Tupper also involved in at least one. [2].

[1] This is the earliest performance advertisement that has been found in the Northampton Mercury (Aug. 9, 1845)

[2] Kurt Gänzl, Victorian Vocalists,  (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2017), p..528

 

1846

The Young Pretender

Mary à Beckett / Mark Lemon, Haymarket Theatre, November 28, 1846.

Occasionally cited as Mary à Beckett's third opera and initially advertised as an Operatic Drama, this was a short, lightweight play with some musical numbers performed by Mr Hudson and Priscilla Horton. The Times (Nov. 30, 1846) wrote that "there are some pretty pieces of vocal music ... but, altogether, the piece is too flimsy even for an hour's satisfactory recreation".

The Seven Maids of Munich, or, the Ghost Tower

George Rodwell / George Rodwell, Princess's Theatre, December 19, 1846.

This was advertised as a one act musical romance.  Both libretto and music were by Rodwell, who claimed in a letter to the Morning Post (Dec. 22, 1846) that it was an entirely original. The Morning Chronicle (Dec. 21, 1846) thought it "lively and agreeable".

 

1847

The Rival Clans

Henry Deval / Henry Deval, Theatre Royal, Newcastle, January 22, 1847

Advertised as "an entirely New Opera in Two Acts" (Newcastle Journal, January 16, 1847) but described elsewhere[1] as a "ballad opera" with music by the Theatre Royal music director, Henry Deval. The Era (February 7, 1847) noted that "the overture was original" perhaps suggesting that some or all of the remainder was not but, as was often the case with ballad opera, took existing ballads or ballad tunes for the majority, if not all, of the vocal numbers. The review in The Era claimed that it was a great success but it does not seem to have been revived

[1] Kathleen Barker, "The Performing Arts in Newcastle upon Tyne", Leisure in Britain, 1780-1939, edited by John K. Walton, James Walvin. (Manchester:: Manchester University Press, 1986), p.58.

 

1848

The Andalusian or The Young Guard

Edward Loder / George Soane, Princess's Theatre, January 20, 1848.

This was described in the Morning Herald (Jan. 21, 1848) as "a little opera...apparently a portion of a larger work...and containing a series of agreeable songs by Mr Loder". Elsewhere it was described as a two act operetta.  It seems to have been a vehicle for the popular soprano, Anna Thillon, and was well received. The Era (Jan. 23, 1848), having noted "the somewhat flimsy plot", wrote that "Mr Loder has introduced some light and pretty music, which, from its unpretending style, disarms criticism. The ballads from their simplicity, are sure to attain popularity". Soane, the librettist, had written The Night Dancers (1846) for Loder. The libretto can be found at Warwick Digital Collections and at Internet Archive.

Jeannette and Jeannot

James Tully / James Henry Horncastle, Theatre Royal, Brighton, September 14, 1848 [1].

The music was by James Tully and the libretto by Horncastle, who were musical director and one of the singers doing a season at Brighton and then touring with the English Opera Company. The opera was reported as given at Portsmouth a few days later and selections from it in Ipswich a month later. It never played at a major London theatre and seems likely to have been an enterprising, but transitory, effort to take advantage of the highly popular song by Charles Jefferys and Charles Glover, "Jeannette and Jeannot", even though it boasted that "the Music all entirely original".  No manuscript appears to have been forwarded to the Lord Chamberlain's office for approval. Another example that capitalised on the song  was Edward Stirling's musical romance, which premiered at the Strand Theatre in London  on November 6,1848. That was sent to the Examiner.   

[1] Brighton Gazette (Sep. 14, 1848)

 

1850

The Sleeper Awakened

George Alexander Macfarren / John Oxenford, Her Majesty's Theatre, November 15, 1850

This was described as a serenata, which would normally feature elements of opera, oratorio and cantata and, in this case, was described as "a short opera without the aid of scenery, dresses and appointments" (The Era, Nov. 24, 1850). It featured as part of a Grand National concert. 

 

1852

The Charmed Harp

Wilhelm Meyer Lutz / John Courtney, Surrey Theatre, August 30, 1852

This was a "romantic operetta" performed as an afterpiece to Balfe's The Devil's in it. The Daily News (Aug. 31, 1852) talked of the dramatic portion being "a jumble of the stalest melodramatic ingredients" while none of the main company vocalists were included. 

 

1853

Pierre

Joseph F. Duggan / Henri Drayton, St. James's Theatre, November, 1853

This was described as a one act operetta and was essentially a vehicle for the Draytons. 

 

1855

The Minstrel's Return, or, The Sultan's Jubilee

Fourness Rolfe / Fourness Rolfe, Theatre Royal, Newcastle, March 22, 1855

George Biddlecombe [1] included this work in his list of operas with words and music by Fourness Rolfe. However, the well known actor Samuel Phelps was booked for a short engagement that week and Shakespeare's  Julius Caesar advertised for that Thursday so it seems more than likely that this was a short afterpiece or similar.  No work of this title was lodged with the Lord Chamberlain and it does not seem to have been performed elsewhere. Rolfe was an actor, comedian and singer with a very varied career mainly in provincial cities but with some London appearances.

[1] George Biddlecombe. Op. Cit., p.336.

 

1856

Never Judge by Appearances

Edward Loder / Henri Drayton,  Theatre Royal, Southampton, September 2, 1856 (?)

The Hampshire Advertiser (September 6, 1856) reported that Henri and Susanna Drayton had appeared in Southampton in their "Duo-musical and Mimetic Entertainment" entitled Illustrated Proverbs, of which the second offering was "Never Judge by Appearances".  Three weeks later the Liverpool Mercury (September 27, 1856) was advertising them at Clayton Hall, Liverpool. By early 1857, they were in the Myddleton Hall, London followed by further provincial cities. The music was by Edward Loder and played on the piano, at least for some of the time by Edward's cousin, George.  In July, 1859, it was submitted to the Examiner of Plays for performance at the Adelphi on July 7, 1859, where it was advertised as a one act opera but still only  featured the Draytons, although it may have had orchestral accompaniment.

The Soldier's Return or Clara and Valentine

Robert Goldbeck / Robert Goldbeck

Goldbeck was a German pianist who took up residency in London for a time. The Morning Chronicle (June 17, 1856) announced that a one act opera of his was about to be produced at Drury Lane. However, there was no obvious sign of it nor was it submitted to the Examiner of Play and by October, 1856, he had left for the US(Morning Post, Oct. 18, 1856). TheMorning Post(May 21, 1857) advertised the publication of the piano score of The Soldier's Return, which was described as "a short comic opera for amateurs". The Liverpool Mercury (Aug. 4, 1885) advertised a comic operetta, The Soldier's Return, at the Rotunda Theatre, Liverpool, which might well refer to this piece while the Wellington Journal and Shrewsbury News (Nov. 27, 1886) specifically  named Goldbeck in its description of a performance of the piece by Mrs Burton's Opera Company in Shrewsbury the following year. This, nearly 30 years later, suggests that it had been circulating in the provinces for many years previously. 

 

1858

The Dream

Michael Costa / William Bartholomew, Birmingham Festival, September 3, 1858

This was a serenata to celebrate the marriage of Princess Victoria to Prince Frederick William of Prussia. Birmingham was its first public performance but it had been given previously at Buckingham Palace on the night of the wedding on January 25, 1858.

 

1859

The Pirate's Isle

Frederick Clay / Benjamin Stephenson, 1959

This operetta was only given a private performance [1]

[1] Stanley Sadie (ed.), Grove Dictionary of Opera. Vol 1 (London: Macmillan, 1992), vol1, p. 878.

 

1860

Garibaldi, or, the Rival Patriots

Frederick Cowen / Rosalind Cowen, Private performance.

A "drawing room operetta" with music by the precocious 8 year old Frederic Cowen with words by his cousin Rosalind and given a private performance at his home.

[1] Christopher J. Parker, The music of Sir Frederic Hymen Cowen (1852-1935) : a critical study (Durham University: Ph.D. thesis,2007  )p.366. Available at  http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/1834/ 

Romance or the Bold Dick Turpin

Henry Leslie / J. Palgrave Simpson, Covent Garden, February 2, 1860

A one act operetta with text by Simpson and music by Leslie.

Queen Topaze

Victor Massé / John Oxenford - George Linley, Her Majesty's Theatre, December 12, 1860.

This was an adaptation by Oxenford, who wrote new dialogue, and Linley, who adapted the songs to the music of Victor Massé's opéra comique, La Reine Topaze.

 

1861

Out of Sight

Frederic Clay / Benjamin Stephenson, Bijou Theatre (Her Majesty's), June 26, 1861.

An operetta.  The Morning Post (June 15, 1861) advertised it for June 26 at the Bijou Theatre "with an entirely new cast and band". It had been given at an amateur concert on July 6, 1860 [1]. The Dublin Daily Express ( June 25, 1861) stated that there had been some amateur performances but that it was now being brought out at the Bijou "to a more general hearing".  Even here though there were amateur vocalists, "who acquitted themselves tolerably well" (The Era, July 14, 1861). The Bijou Theatre was an "elegant little theatre attached to the spacious building to the Haymarket Italian Opera" (Her Majesty's Theatre).

[1] Daily News (July 2, 1860)

 

1862

Court and Cottage,

Frederic Clay / Tom Taylor, Covent Garden, March 22, 1862

An operetta by Clay to text by Taylor.  It was originally scheduled for March 15 as part of Harrison's benefit but was postponed for some undisclosed reason until March 22 and Louisa Pyne's benefit. She sung in it. The advertisements referred to it as an operetta and it was only ever an afterpiece to the main work, in this instance to Meyerbeer's Dinorah.

Law versus Love

George Linley / George Linley, Princess's Theatre, December 8, 1862.

A one act comedietta with words and music by George Linley.

 

1863

Freya's Gift

George Alexander Mafarren / John Oxenford, Covent Garden, March 10, 1863.

Described as an Allegorical Masque to mark the marriage of the Prince of Wales to Princess Alexandra of Denmark.

A Lord for an hour

G.L.Saunders / G.L. Saunders, Theatre Royal, Sheffield, July 17, 1863.

An operetta with words and music by Alderman G.L. Saunders and sung by the Grand English Opera Company after their performance of Wallace's Lurline.

Jessy Lea

George Alexander Mafarren / John Oxenford, The Gallery of Illustration, November 2, 1863.

Thomas and Priscilla German Reed opened the Gallery of Illustration with the aim of staging chamber operas, usually with piano or piano and harmonium accompaniment, and with the hope of attracting those repelled by the notion of going to a public theatre.  Jessy Lea with music by  Macfarren and Oxenford was their first, very successful, offering.

 

1864

Fanchette

William Charles Levey / John Maddison Morton, Covent Garden, January 4, 1864

Described as a musical farce and a one act operetta with words by Morton and music by Levey. It was performed by the Pyne-Harrison company and was revived into the 1870s.  Rather doubtfully, it was claimed to have had a run of over 300 nights (Northampton Mercury, June 15, 1878)

The Rival Beauties

Alberto Randegger / John Pratt Wooler, Theatre Royal, Leeds, May 2, 1864.

Although described as a new comic opera given by the London Operetta Company [1], the vocal score described it as an operetta, as did press reports, such as The Era (May 15, 1864). The music was by Randegger and the text by Wooler. Performances in Manchester and the Crystal Palace followed through the rest of May and early June. It was revived from time to time in London and the provinces until at least the 1889.

[1] Leeds Mercury (May 2, 1864)

The Oracle

Adolph Gollmick / Carl Gollmick, Victoria Hall, Bayswater (Bijou Theatre), July 6, 1864.

Sometimes described as a one act comic opera and sometimes as an operetta. The libretto was by Adolph's father, Carl. See http://www.mmm2.mugemir.de/doku.php?id=gollmick for more details on the Gollmick family. The first performance was for a charity event on July 6, 1864 and other performances followed [1]. However, the Lord Chamberlain's licence was only sent on February 21, 1865. Perhaps Gollmick had thought that amateur performances did not require a licence or else it was prior to an intended professional performance that never materialised.

[1] Bayswater Chronicle (July 23, 1864). The Era (Feb.12, 1865) described a performance by the Westbourne Operetta Society, which had been created by Gollmick, on February 6, 1865, at the Victoria Hall. It called it a two act operetta.

The Sleeping Queen

Michael William Balfe / Henry Brougham Farnie, The Gallery of Illustration, September 1, 1864

An operetta with music by Balfe and text by Farnie.  One of the singers was Thomas Whiffen, who became the husband of Louisa Pyne's niece, Blanche. The following year Balfe developed it into a two act opera but this was never performed. A video of a production by the DIT Conservatory, Dublin,  can be seen at https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLECSSzvbzXlAw2IScFegEC9kU161PtLFd

The Soldier's Legacy

George Alexander Macfarren / John Oxenford, The Gallery of Illustration, October 19, 1864

Another successful chamber opera by Macfarren and Oxenford.

The Bride of Song

Julius Benedict / Henry Brougham Farnie, Covent Garden, December 3, 1864

A one act operetta with music by Benedict and text by Farnie

Punchinello

William Charles Levey / Henry Brougham Farnie, Her Majesty's, December 28, 1864

The vocal score (here) and the libretto described it as a one act comic opera. However, as it only has one act and needed just 5 singers with a chorus being optional, it has not been included as an English opera. Elsewhere it was called an operetta, e.g. advertisement in The Standard (Dec. 30, 1864).  The music was by Levey and text by Farnie.

 

1865

The period 1865 into early 1866 marked a clear end to the type of opera and organisation that had been familiar over the previous thirty or so years of English opera. The most obvious sign was the hasty disbandment of the Royal English Opera Company (Limited) at Covent Garden, when the performance on the evening of February 17, 1866, was called off because there was no money to pay singers or backstage staff [1], but the continued inability to sustain a viable company derived from more deep rooted causes.

It had become increasingly obvious in the 1860s that the dialogue and song model of English opera could not deliver the depth and range of drama and emotion that continental through composed opera achieved. Partly this was down to the poor quality of librettists and lesser qualities of composers but more so to the irregular and uneven nature of song interrupted by dialogue that broke continuity and undermined dramatic climaxes. Even continental operas with dialogue, such as Gounod's Faust and Bizet's Carmen, only achieved their full popularity after the dialogue had been converted to recitative. Related to this, the primacy of melody that reigned at the beginning of the 19th century and was usually associated with Italian opera, gradually gave way to more sophisticated musical ideas, particularly harmony, which were sometimes labelled "scientific" and were initially associated with German orchestral works. Although English opera sometimes turned to extended "scenas", which gave scope for greater musical sophistication, at its heart it relied on melody and thus was unable to keep abreast of the new ideas and expectations.

Instead, encouraged by the success of opéra-bouffe imported from France in the late 1850s and of small scale opera di camera at places such as The Gallery of Illustration, English opera morphed into a range of overlapping, generally less dramatic and ambitious dialogue and song forms: operetta, opera di camera, comic opera and the musical. The Royal English Opera Company (Limited) tried to leaven its more serious offerings with some operetta while Elliott Galer and Fanny Reeves took over the New Royalty theatre and dedicated it solely to lightweight, smaller scale, works. Neither achieved a strong and sustainable business but pointed in a direction that others would follow with more success.

[1] The Era (Feb. 25, 1866) includes some of the conflicting correspondence surrounding the closure

Constance

Frederic Clay / Thomas W. Robertson, Covent Garden, January 28, 1865

This was one of a number of lighter works produced by the Royal English Opera Company (Limited) as they sought to find a viable artistic and economic future. It managed only a handful of performances.

It was listed as an operetta on the manuscript sent to the Examiner and usually called such in the press but there were occasional references to it as an opera, as on the title of the vocal score (opposite).

The chorus and band parts at the sale of the Royal English Opera (Limited) effects went for  22 shillings [1].

[1]The Era (Apr. 8, 1866)

pic

The River Sprite

Frank Mori / George Linley, Covent Garden, February 9, 1865

This was called an operetta on the manuscript sent to the Examiner but was often advertised as a one act opera. The confusion as to classification can be seen in The Era (Feb. 12, 1865) which first referred to it as a one act opera in its review but later as an operetta.  According to The Times (Feb. 13, 1865) it had originally been composed three years previously for the Pyne and Harrison Company at Covent Garden.

It only ran until February 25 but was revived on February 16, 1866 at Covent Garden. However, it managed just one performance before the company folded. It was then given in September later that year in Newcastle by Edmund Rosenthal's English Grand Opera Company with Florence Lancia singing the lead as she had at its premiere.

pic

The sale of the chorus and band parts at the sale of the Royal English Opera (Limited) effects went for less than 22 shillings [1]. There is an online printed libretto at Google Books and a vocal score at Google Books.

[1]The Era (Apr. 8, 1866)

 

Elliot Galer and Fanny Reeves at the New Royalty Theatre

Galer and Reeves took over the New Royalty Theatre in September, 1865, with Reeves named as Directress. Their aim was to run a small scale company devoted to lightweight operettas, comic operas, burlesques etc. that required a smaller company than usual with English opera. The limited aspirations and reduced demands on the performers are clear from The Press [London] (Sep 9, 1865) comment that: "Castle Grim will be a boon to amateurs for drawing-room performances, as it is so arranged in the complete edition published by Messrs Metzler and Co. that it can be played with or without chorus".

Although both were seasoned English opera singers who had run their own touring companies, they did not attempt any English opera except Wallace's Maritana for Reeves's benefit on March 18, 1866, when extra forces were drafted in [1]. That performance also marked the end of their tenure. Their enterprise was, presumably, financially unsuccessful as there was no other obvious reason for them to finish [2].

While at the New Royalty, they staged a number of new works, the main ones being:

George Allen's Castle Grim, September 2, 1865

Wilhelm Meyer Lutz's Felix or the Festival of Roses, October 23, 1865

John Mallandaine's Love's Limit, January 6, 1866

John Mallandaine's Sylvia, or the Forest Flower, February 17, 1866

[1] The Era (Mar. 18, 1866)

[2] The Era (Mar. 11, 1866) carried an advertisement that the theatre was open for hire so there was no other person or company taking over immediately. The following week, much of the company decamped to the Royal Pavilion Theatre for a series of five concerts, so they did not have immediate other engagements to go to. Galer and Reeves joined Annie Thirlwall's English Opera Company at the start of April with Galer as joint manager, but it seems unlikely they would take on the risky finances and rigours of a provincial tour if they had a thriving business in London. Despite the many glowing reviews, the Illustrated Sporting News (Jan. 13, 1866) had summed up their performance of Love's Limit; "We are convinced the public will support a first rate operetta theatre - but not a second rate one" and had clearly placed them in the latter.