Title header



 

 


Sir Julius Benedict

1804-1885

 

Benedict's Life and Work

Sir Julius (Jules) Benedict (1804-1885) was born in Germany and had a much travelled early career beginning with a thorough grounding in music from his studies with Hummel and Weber, whose autobiography he was later to write. He also met Beethoven. He was then employed by Domenico Barbaja in 1823, first as a conductor in Vienna and then, in 1826, in Naples. While there he composed three operas but with little success. In 1834, he left Naples for Paris but, on Malibran's advice, moved on to London in 1835, where he settled for the remainder of his life, eventually taking British nationality and receiving a knighthood in 1871[1].

Once established in London he created The Gipsy's Warning, which opened at Drury Lane in 1838. Two further operas The Brides of Venice (1844) and The Crusaders (1846) were followed by a gap of some 16 years before The Lily of Killarney (1862). During this time as well as composing a number of oratorios, cantatas, piano concertos and songs, Benedict was busy conducting in various London theatres, for the Liverpool Philharmonic and at the Norwich Festival, organising  concerts and performing as a piano soloist and accompanist including for Jenny Lind on her 1850-51 tour of the US [2]. The details of his early career documented by Philip Carli can be found here.

pic

New York Public Library

 

Benedict returned from his US tour in August 1851 a wealthy man and took his family on a holiday in Europe the following month. Unfortunately, in the October, his son was killed in an accident on the river Rhone.  His wife never recovered from the shock and died in April the next year, followed by his father in the July. For a time he ceased much of his public activities, other than teaching, but he still managed to organise and conduct the Norwich Festival in September 1852 and his annual concert the following year.

Benedict 

Gradually his career picked up its old pace and, in 1862, he produced his most popular opera, The Lily of Killarney, for the Pyne-Harrison company. His next was The Bride of Song in 1864 but, with its failure, he gave up composing opera for good and concentrated on his many other activities. Unfortunately one of these was a part share with Frederick Gye in an opera tour in 1875 that was a disastrous failure and cost him a considerable sum [3]. 

In December 1879, he married one of his pupils, Mary Fortey, over 50 years his junior. His final years were somewhat clouded by financial problems, which seemed partly to do with the 1875 opera tour but must have included other ill judged investments. A testimonial was initiated in 1884 to help him and a two day Jubilee celebration marking his 50 years in Britain was organised in 1885. Benedict died in Manchester on June 5, 1885 just before they were due to happen but they went ahead nevertheless with the proceeds going to "Lady Benedict, who is left, we regret to say, in anything but affluent circumstances"[4].

There is a letter to the cleric, poet and librettist,  Archer Gurney, that throws an interesting light on the composer's view of his libretto for Die Bräute von Venedig, the German version of The Brides of Venice, which had been translated and adapted by Karl Klingemann[5].

 

                                                                                            Manchester Square, 20 January 1845.

Dear Mr.Gurney

 

I feel equally flattered and honoured that you should have taken so much trouble about the second Act of my Opera. I too have felt all the deficiencies in the plot and the absurdities you so forcibly point out - and ever since its production have been hard at work to alter and remove these glaring faults. Unfortunately this change has been completed by my friend Mr Klingemann in German, and now I fear it will be too late to avail myself of some very striking and dramatic situations which you have most skilfully introduced - principally the meeting of Alberto and Sorango - and the last scene which has in your version an immense power and interest.

 

&c. &c.

Yours truly & obliged Jules Benedict.

 

[1] The knighthood also marked a switch from him using the first name "Jules" to "Julius".

[2] The Hampshire Advertiser (Jan. 10, 1852)  reported that Benedict had agreed to write an account of the tour for a publisher but nothing appeared. Many years later he did contribute an article on her to Scribner's Monthly, vol. 22 (New York: The Century Co., 1881), pp 120 - 132). As might be expected he gave a glowing portrait of Lind somewhat at odds with his diary entries at the time, at one point declaring "I don't know how much longer I can stand these indignities heaped upon me". (email from Philip Carli, July 19, 2023) 

[3] Herman Klein, Musicians and Mummers. (London: Cassell and Company, 1925), p.93. Paul Rodmell, Opera in the British Isles, 1875-1918. (Farnham, UK: Ashgate Publishing Ltd., 2013), p.153 ftn 57, quoted around £3000 loss. 

[4] Daily Telegraph (June 6, 1885). Despite the many references to his straitened circumstances, Benedict left over £6600 in his will, in the region of £1,000,000 today.

[5] Augustus Gurney, A Remarkable Clerical Career.  ed. David Gurney (Market Harborough: Troubadour, 2025), ebook - https://troubador.co.uk/bookshop/biography/a-remarkable-clerical-career , pp. 347-348.

  

Recordings of Benedict's Works

Commercial Opera Recordings
There are no complete commercial recordings of Benedict's operas, although a few excerpts from Benedict's The Lily of Killarney as well as from Balfe's The Bohemian Girl and Wallace's Maritana have been reissued on  EMI Classics 0094633594821 in 2005 with an orchestra conducted by Havelock Ellis.

Private Opera Recordings
The Lily of Killarney,   
BBC Northern Orchestra conducted by Stanford Robinson, Rare Recorded Editions RRE 157/8, 1968. It is available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cKT5tsIcKY  and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sgRpnsL0k74
 
The BBC included excerpts in their "Britannia at the Opera" series, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70vArcHoz1E. There are also excerpts from a National Concert Hall, Dublin, concert https://www.
youtube.com/watch?v=gJDxI-TSNHM  and  Glasnevin Musical Society - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rveppGqbHG8 . There are several recordings of individual songs on youtube.com

There is a recording of the overture to his opera The Crusaders, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQKcUYANDRY

Other works

overtures

His overture to The Lily of Killarney is included in the Victorian Opera Northwest recording of a number of Victorian English opera overtures on SOMM CD 0123 : British Opera Overtures. More detail on the content can be found here.

The most substantial recording of his works are the two piano concertos played by Howard Shelley with the Tasmanian Symphony Orchestra on Hyperion CDA67720, 2009.  The CD also includes a Concertstück for piano and orchestra by Walter Macfarren, brother of Sir George Alexander Macfarren.

There is a private recording of his Symphony No.1 played by the Ulster Orchestra, conducted by Myer Fredman at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pDapIX0JaOk&t=166s

A few of Benedict's songs and short pieces for piano and other instruments are occasionally found on anthologies.

 

Books and articles on Benedict

There do not appear to be any books devoted to Benedict.  Nathaniel P. Willis,  Memoranda of the life of Jenny Lind, (Philadelphia: Robert E. Peterson, 1851) included a short chapter on Benedict.  There is also a short chapter in George Biddlecombe's, English opera from 1834 to 1864 with particular reference to the works of Michael Balfe. (New York: Garland Publishing, 1994), pp. 143-149.

There is some material on Benedict in Fiona Palmer's "Conductors and Self-Promotion in the British Marketplace", The Idea of Art Music in a Commercial World, 1800-1930. (Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2016), pp. 130 - 151. The article can be found online at https://mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/7729/1/FP_
Idea%20of%20Art%20Music.pdf .  Palmer also has a chapter on Benedict's and William Cusins' times as conductors of the Liverpool and London Philharmonic societies in Fiona Palmer, Conductors in Britain, 1870 - 1914. (Woodbridge: Boydell Press, 2016), pp. 46 - 92.

Weberiana (Summer 2009) , pp 125-190, carries a lengthy biographical article (in German) by Eveline Bartlitz and Frank Ziegler entitled "Julius Benedict, Ein Komponist zwischen Weber, Rossini und Mendelssohn". [1]

The Musical Times (Jul.1, 1885), pp. 385-386, carried a lengthy obituary.

William Spark's Musical memories. 3rd edition (London: W. Reeves, 1909), pp. 13-23 has a short biography.  Spark knew him but even so it is not particularly insightful.

A descendent of Benedict, Brian Brooks wrote an article on him for the Donizetti Society Newsletter, no. 29, May 1882, see here.

See the Books page for more general histories of this era.

   

[1] Thanks to Philip Carli for this reference

 

Scores and librettos

IMSLP has some scores but none of the English operas. See  https://www.englishromanticopera.org/librettos.
htm for links to his English opera librettos. Leeds University claimed to have a score of Act 1 of The  Gipsy's Warning but it seems to have been lost. The Royal College of Music, London, has a full score but listed as The Gipsies' Warning (5037 a&b) [1]

 

[1]] Thanks to Philip Carli for this reference

 

Web pages / Online

There are no known dedicated websites to Benedict.