Title header



 

 


Robin Goodfellow,
or The Frolics of Puck

 Music by Edward J. Loder

Libretto by John Frederick Smith

Princess's Theatre, London
December 6, 1848

Advertised as A Fairy Ballad Opera 

pic

Playbill for Robin Goodfellow, January 24, 1849, POS/LDN PRS/0595993 Playbill Collection,
supplied by Special Collections and Archives, University of Kent.

 

Cast

The cast as listed in the Songs, Choruses etc. of the opera (London: S.G.Fairbrother, 1848(?) )

Sir Richard Morton(?)

Sir Hyacinth Lutestring

Walter Barton

Goodboy

Rockton

 

Puck (Robin Goodfellow)

Titania (Queen of the Fairies)

Lady Alice

Mabel

Oberon (King of the Fairies)

Mustard Seed

Gnatfly

Maydew

Rosebud

- Willoughby Weiss

- Mr. Henry (James Henry Horncastle)

- Charles Braham

- James  Paulo

- Charles Fisher  

 

- Elizabeth Poole

- Georgiana Smithson

- Emma Stanley

- Georgina Weiss

- Miss Kenworthy

- Miss Wilkinson

- Miss Weymouth

- Carlotta Le Clercq

- Georgina Barrett (Mrs Weiss)

 

History

This was yet another work provided by Loder in his capacity of music director of the Princess's Theatre. It was essentially a number of ballads together with incidental music but without ensembles and it is a marginal case as to whether to classify it as an English opera.  Although the vocal score implied that Loder had written the libretto, it appears[1] to have been by John Frederick Smith, a well known novelist of the day and who had already been identified as a possible librettist of Loder's  Francis the First .

John Maddox, the Princess's manager, in his covering letter to the examiner said that it was sent to be licenced on November 25, 1848, with a plan to perform it on December 2, 1848. It is not clear whether the latter date was deliberately listed earlier in order to ensure that it was licenced in time or whether the premiere date slipped.

 

Plot

The Daily News (December 7, 1848) summarised the plot as:

Puck, or Robin Goodfellow, having incurred Queen Titania’s displeasure, is expelled the realms of Fairy Land, and his banishment is to be perpetual, unless within a given time he find out what is dearest to a woman’s heart. He is allowed three guesses: the failure of the last is to seal his doom. He repairs to earth where – it being the period of the Commonwealth - he finds in the family of the Royalist, Sir Richard Morton, a disguised Cromwellian [Rookton], seeking to gain Sir Richard’s estates and his daughter, by fastening a plot upon this worthy knight. The young lady, however, has fixed her affections upon Walter Barton, her only objection to him being that he is a puritan. This objection he seeks to remove by assuming a cavalier costume and manner. An interview of the lovers induces Robin Goodfellow to suppose that love is the master-passion of the fair sex: his statement to that effect, however, is rejected by Titania. On a subsequent visit to the earth he finds Sir Richard betrayed by the nefarious Rookton, but saved by the heroism of Walter Barton; his observations of Lady Alice’s conduct on this occasion makes him conclude that faith is the master passion with woman: the solution not being adopted by Titania, he makes a third experiment, and ascertains from the future proceedings of the Lady Alice with her lover, that to have her will is what is dearest to woman’s heart, and Titania owning the soft impeachment, Robin Goodfellow is received into the bosom of his family, and so the piece ends.

 

Reception

The Standard (December 8, 1848) thought it
both a pretty story and pretty music" adding that "The overture, of Weberish hue, exhibits Mr. Loder's masterly skill in writing for the orchestra; and the accompaniments to the ballads and concerted pieces are equally indicative of taste, judgment, and propriety of effect.  Pity there is not a better band to do them justice.

The Morning Post (December 9, 1848) was less complimentary.
The author [of the text] has been anything but fortunate in the amalgamation [of fairy and domestic]". While on the music, it thought that:  "There is considerable merit in the orchestration, which is in the best school, and is both fanciful and effective; but there is a want of freshness in the melodies, which are, in the majority of instances, either too laboured or too trite.

 The Examiner (December 9, 1848) disagreed.
The story is better than usual, the actual and the fanciful being rather prettily blended in it; and pieces of higher musical pretension have been much less entertaining than Robin Goodfellow.

The Musical World (December 9, 1848) also liked the work and in a follow up two weeks later remarked:
Mr Loder’s delightful opera, Robin Goodfellow, still continues its successful career.  The music becomes more acceptable at every hearing, and the various ballads and concerted pieces are nightly received with increased applause.

 

Scores and Librettos

The libretto is only available in manuscript at the British Library, Add MS 43015, ff. 286-307b. A transcript can be found here. The printed Songs, Choruses etc of the opera (London: S.G. Fairbrother, 1846) were made available in a scan from the British Library. Given their ongoing problems, that scan is made available here. There are some differences in the printed Songs from the manuscript, which are noted in the transcript. There are not many and they are not very significant.

The vocal score is also in the British Library.

 

Recordings

None are known

 

Books, Articles, Online

David Chandler's "Edward Loder and his Librettos" (pp. 229 - 231) in Nicholas Temperley (ed.),  Musicians of Bath and Beyond: Edward Loder (1809-1865) and his Family, (Woodbridge: The Boydell Press, 2016) discuss the libretto.

[1]Andrew, King (ed.), The London Journal, 1845-83, (Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing, 2004), p.103