![]() |
|
|
Joan of ArcMusic by Michael William BalfeLibretto by Edward Fitzball
Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, London
|
| Charles VII of France | - Mr Baker |
| Count Dunois | - John Templeton |
|
Beauvais (Enemy to the King and Dunois) |
- Mr Anderson [1] |
| Theodore (a young Vintager) | - Michael William Balfe |
|
Baudricourt (Provost of Vancouleurs) |
- Frank Cooke |
| John of Luxembourg | - Mr Howell [2] |
|
Renaud (Joan's Uncle, Host of the "Silver Lily") |
- Theodore Giubilei |
| Badet (his Nephew, a Peasant) | - Arthur Edwards Seguin |
| Bertraud (a Gaoler) | - Mr. Hughes |
|
Xantrilles
(Generals with Joan) Picardy |
-
Mr King - Mr Honner |
| Corporal Twist | - Mr S Jones |
| Vendome (Officer under Luxembourg) | - Mr Mears |
| Joan of Arc | - Emma Romer |
| Agnes Sorel | - Mrs Anderson [3] |
| St Catherine | - Sally Forde |
| Madeleon (a Villager) | - Elizabeth Poole |
Conductor - Tom Cooke ? [4]
[1] - Andersen was replaced by James Frazer when the opera was revived in February 1838
[2] - Howell was replaced by Mr Harris for the 1838 revival
[3] - The playbill for later in the run has Agnes Sorel played by Miss Fitzwalter. Anderson returned for the 1838 revival.
[4] Balfe would have been expected to conduct the first few performances, but, as he was performing, Tom Cooke conducted.
Alfred Bunn, manager of Drury Lane, was not only facing increasing financial pressures but was involved in disputes with the Lord Chamberlain, beginning with his attempt to stage John Barnett's Fair Rosamond on prohibited Wednesdays and Fridays during Lent. Despite this and notwithstanding the failure of Catherine Grey, Bunn turned again to Balfe for a new opera to a libretto by Fitzball based, very loosely, on the history of Joan of Arc. Fitzball had first produced a Joan of Arc in 1822 for Sadler's Wells. It was a melodrama rather than an opera and continued to be played for several years.
The opera's appearance had been "long promised" [1] which gave Charles Macready, manager at Covent Garden and who hated Bunn [2], the chance of a spoiling manoeuvre. Two days before the Balfe premiere, Covent Garden staged a new play by Thomas J. Serle also about Joan of Arc [3]. At its premiere Macready recorded in his diary that there was considerable disturbance in Mr Almond's box and he had to go and remonstrate with the occupants. Almond was Emma Romer's married name and it seems plausible that a group, possibly including Romer, went to make their feelings felt about this attempt to upstage the Drury Lane opera [4].
The opera had a respectable but hardly overwhelming run. There were 21 performances in 1837 [5] and at least two in 1838, although on February 21, 1838, it was relegated to the half price slot. Balfe staged it in Dublin (4 full performances and a few with just one or two acts) and Belfast when he brought a company over in February and March, 1840. In May, he included it in a one night staging of scenes from several of his operas in Plymouth. His wife, Lina, was Joan in all the 1840 performances. There seem to have been no further performances although numbers from the opera continued to be given in concerts for a few years.
| The opera seems to have been the first stage production to use limelight [6], rather grandly named in the bill as Phoshelioulamproteron. However, the bills for later in December omit any reference so that either it had broken down or it was a failure. A somewhat jaundiced Examiner (Dec. 3, 1837) wrote that "It turned out to be a very ordinary green light". |
![]() Theatrical Observer (Dec. 12, 1837) |
[1] The Atlas (Dec. 3, 1837)
[2] In 1836, Macready had got so exasperated with Bunn that he had assaulted him and ended up paying him £150 damages.
[3] A more famous example was Drury Lane's attempt to upstage Carl Maria von Weber's opera Oberon at Covent Garden in 1826 by its hasty production of Henry Bishop's Aladdin. That was a fiasco. However, in the Joan of Arc case, Covent Garden's version had a rather longer life than the opera, its success relying on its spectacle rather than literary worth.
[4] "November 28th. - The play had scarcely begun when Robertson rushed down to tell me that some persons in Mr. Almond's box were making a disturbance, and had been twice called to by the pit. I hastened up to the box, and entering it said : 'I understand this box is taken by a person of the name of Almond ; the conduct of the persons here has twice attracted the notice of the audience. I beg you to understand that if any similar outrage occurs I shall hold Mr. Almond responsible. My name is Mr. Macready'. William Toynbee (ed.), The Diaries of William Charles Macready, Vol. 1 (New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1912). p.428. A little further on Macready makes plain that there were ladies in the box who complained about his behaviour.
[5] Basil Walsh's, Michael W. Balfe. (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 2008), p.193, stated a total of 22 performances but the playbill for December 19, 1837 ( http://storage.googleapis.com/blplaybills.org/large2/lsidyv3fa2d0b5_082.jpeg ) claimed that it was the 17th performance and that it was the last performance but four. Thus, together with the February performances, there were at least 23 performances in London. Alfred Bunn, The Stage: both before and behind the curtain. Vol. 3 (London: Richard Bentley, 1840), p. 244 stated that there were 22 performances but it is not clear what years were covered..
[6] Sometimes called the Drummond light after its inventor Thomas Drummond. It burnt oxygen with another flammable gas to produce a very hot flame which was directed at a piece of calcium oxide (quicklime) to produce an intense and focusable white light.
For some reason the libretto is missing from the British Library's collection of the Lord Chamberlain's Plays, although the Examiner would have seen and passed it for staging. Thus the spoken dialogue is not available although most of the sung items were published [1]. The lack of the dialogue prevents a detailed comparison but, rather unusually given the contemporary propensity to copy and reuse material, Fitzball's libretto did not appear to draw in any significant way on his 1822 melodrama [2]. Fitzball did not even recycle the two musical items from it. This was, no doubt, because the melodrama was still playing [3]. Both plots were broadly similar with almost no English involvement and ending with Joan being rescued but many details were different and the opera was altogether lighter in tone. In the melodrama, the love interest was centred on Joan's sister, Lucelle, and boyfriend, Florine, neither of whom appeared in the opera. Joan was dedicated to rescuing France. In the opera, Joan has a lover, Theodore, who joins her on the campaign and who was to have been immolated with her. In the melodrama, it was her father who took this supporting role. He does not appear in the opera.
As in his melodrama, Fitzball claimed that his libretto was "principally founded on Southey's popular poem". However, the Morning Chronicle (Dec. 1, 1837) was skeptical, "its incidents, such as they are, are founded on one or two of the most familiarly known occurrences in the life of the heroine ...with the addition of some love passages, and a quantity of dull buffoonery, which is assuredly not to be found in Southey's poem. It also pointed out that "the catastrophe is utterly at variance with historical truth" with Joan being rescued rather than burning at the stake and outlined the plot:
Joan is represented, of course, as a country girl, who has dreams and visions of the salvation of her country through her means. Her character is discovered by the Count Dunois, by whom she is introduced to the King, and placed by him at the head of the French forces. She is betrayed by a certain Beauvais, the leader of a faction, into the hands of her enemies; and is about to be committed to the flames in the market-place of Rouen, when the French suddenly carry the place by assault, and Joan is restored to liberty and the arms of her lover [Theodore], a young peasant who had followed her to the war and in attempting to save her was on the point of sharing her fate. This, with the Irish brogue of Corporal O'Twist, and the humours of a cowardly country clown and a flippant village lass, is the substance of a piece which is longer than a regular five-act play.
[1] One exception was a song sung by Mrs Anderson (Josephine Bartolozzi ) which some thought poor and all agreed had been badly sung, "disastrous singing" (The Musical World, Dec. 8, 1837, p.202).
[2] Larry Stephen Clinton, The Terrible Fitzball: The Melodrammatist of the Macabre. (Bowling Green, Ohio: Bowling Green State University Popular Press, 1993), p.181, claimed that the 1837 performance was a revival of the 1822 melodrama but this is not the case.
[3] Edward Fitzball, Thirty Five Years of a Dramatic Author's Life. Vol. 2, (London: T.C. Newby, 1859), p.122. British Library playbills has one for a performance in Weymouth on August 29, 1838.
The first night audience was enthusiastic, "Nothing could be more entirely triumphant than the success of the opera" [1], but that must have tailed off fairly quickly given the opera's short life [2]. The Morning Chronicle (Dec. 1, 1837) noted that "Though the applause was frequently loud and vehement, yet some parts of the piece went very heavily off; and its being greatly shortened seems indispensible to its success". Bunn posted a bill with two pages of glowing comments judiciously plucked from a number of newspapers. In particular he quoted from The Examiner (Dec. 3, 1837), who in turn had quoted from the Morning Chronicle with the aim of showing that even the usual Balfe's supporters were unenthusiastic about the opera. Bunn took some positive comments from the Chronicle quote and included them as coming from The Examiner. The Examiner (Dec. 17, 1837) was incensed and returned to its critique in more detail:
We have described the verse and prose part of the production as the merest trash ... Mr Balfe's school of writing has always been founded upon the very worst model, namely, that introduced by the successors and puerile imitators of Rossini... Joan of Arc is, in short, the worst of this author's productions, and we hope it may be the last we shall be doomed to listen to...from beginning to end the whole thing is an outrage to common sense.
It advised that it would be best to turn the whole thing into a pantomime for the upcoming Christmas season.
The Musical World (Dec. 8, 1872), p. 202, also left little doubt as to its opinion:
Mr Balfe has been deplorably unfortunate in his new opera. Not only is the whole machinery of his story - plot, dialogue, versification (for it were profane to connect the word "poetry" with such writing), conceived in the very insolence of degradation; but his music, by the consent of all professors, is a mere reminiscence of his former productions; and of these not the best."
Reviewing Balfe's career on April 1, 1848, the Musical World (p. 208) admitted that there was "some ambitious writing" in the opera.
The Morning Post (Dec. 1, 1837) was generally positive:
It is greatly to be regretted that the composer had not better materials to work upon. The language is execrable throughout. To call the trash that is printed in the books of the opera poetry would be absurd. Notwithstanding these disadvantages, Balfe has produced an opera which will not only add to his already high reputation, but be the means of filling the treasury of the theatre.
Unfortunately for Balfe and Bunn, The Court Magazine and Monthly Critic (Jan. 1838), p.107, was rather nearer the mark that "it will neither add to Mr Balfe's fame, nor put many gold pieces into Mr. Bunn's pocket".
Henry Chorley at The Athenaeum (Dec.2, 1837) was also more supportive writing that "it may be said to have been decidedly successful" and, on the whole, had "been carefully rehearsed", which was not always the case at this time. While he thought the libretto "tolerable" though needing reduction, the saving of Joan was "intolerable; and when she is snatched from the flames, his manuscript ought to have been thrown into them". However he thought the music pleasing and "in some parts decidedly so". Although Balfe was not an original composer, his "reminiscences" were well handled and had "an air of novelty, if not a novelty of air".
As with all commentators, The Sun (Dec.1, 1837) had little time for the libretto and thought that the opera "might be denominated comic, from the undue prominence which it gives to a few humourous characters, and its more important incidents are not connected in any force of progressive interest". However, it was more positive about the music "On the whole Mr Balfe's portion of the opera is calculated to make it a favourite for some time, and to reflect new honour upon himself". The next day as well as a more detailed look at the opera, it had a long paean to Balfe, which suggests an element of partisanship had crept in:
The extraordinary success which has attended the representations of his new opera, Joan of Arc, must be gall and wormwood to his contemptible calumniators. It is, however, an invariable attendant upon true genius to be assailed by every species of detractors.
The Morning Chronicle (Dec. 1, 1837) having dismissed the libretto, as mentioned above, thought that "in the music there is much to approve, though it will not add, we think, to the author's laurels". It then went on to list Balfe's faults and to bemoan that the music had
nothing characteristic of the age, the country, or the personages; nothing that breathes a high and chivalrous spirit, or is redolent of France in the olden time; very little that might not have been equally applied to almost any subject, serious or comic, that might be imagined".
This is rather contrary to William Barrett's assessment in his biography of Balfe [3] that claimed that Balfe had "aimed at a loftier and more ambitious style", which proved to be "too high above the the heads of the public"[4]. Barrett thought the main reason for its limited success was that the "edge had been taken off the appetite of the public" by Covent Garden's spoiler.
As often, the scenery and staging were praised although generally thought to be inferior to Serle's Joan of Arc at Covent Garden. Emma Romer was, for the most part, praised [5]. The Morning Post (Dec. 1, 1837) wrote that "Miss Romer's acting and singing were far superior to anything she has yet attempted, and this is no insignificant eulogium", while The Observer (Dec. 3, 1837) said that "she sang with her usual expressiveness and sincerity, if we may use the phrase, but [was] overdelicate for the personation of the martial heroine of France". She and Balfe were called before the curtain at the end.
[1] The Globe (Dec. 1, 1837)
[2] The News (Dec. 10, 1837), less than two weeks later, was then talking of "very indifferent houses".
[3] William M. Barrett, Balfe, his life and work.(London: William Reeves Bookseller Ltd., 1883), pp. 118-119. Fitzball, Thirty Five years, p.124, did not agree about the Covent Garden Joan, writing that "it did us no harm as far as I was ever aware of", although he might not have remembered clearly as he went on to claim that it "ran a great number of nights to excellent houses".
[4] An unattributed quote by Barrett.
[5] Chorley was one of the dissenters judging that she "was not in very good voice, but she exerted herself much.
The Lord Chamberlain's Day Book (Add 53702) shows two works entitled Joan of Arc being signed off, one at Covent Garden, the other with no theatre named but, presumably, Balfe's opera at Drury Lane.[1] No date was given for the signoff other than 1837 and no manuscript seems to have been included in the main collection. The words of the vocal items can be found at the Library of Congress and the Hathi Trust.
A vocal score (System number: 004191081), scores of some numbers and fragments of the score from his sketchbooks are available in the British Library, as is the autograph score donated by Balfe's wife, Lina (Add MS 29331-29332). William Tyldesley, Michael William Balfe: his life and English operas. (Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing, 2003), p.76, notes that these sources are quite difficult to reconcile and show evidence of late changes (Tyldesley talks of the libretto but is referring just to the text of the vocal items). There is a piano score of the song "I would be a soldier still" in the LoC and "The peace of the valley" at HathiTrust . Liverpool City Council have a vocal score.
There are two editions of Fitzball's earlier melodrama in the British Library (System numbers: 000182344 and 010229998). An edition can also be found at Archive.org. Because it is was performed when John Larpent was still Examiner, the original manuscript is in the Huntington Library (LA 2312 ) [2].
[1] The records for the earlier years in the Day Book are a later compilation rather than done at the time of reception of the manuscript and hence are sometimes missing information
[2] Larpent collected many of the post 1737 manuscripts prior to his tenure and added the ones submitted during it. On his death, his wife sold the collection to much public opposition. Eventually, his collection ended up at the Henry E. Huntington Library, San Marino, California. A poor copy on opaque microfilm sheets is held at the British Library (Cup.901.a.11) and there is expensive online access. After 1824, the manuscripts became state property and are now lodged in the British Library. For a more general discussion on the role of the Examiner and state censorship, see R. Burdekin, A Note on Censorship in the 19th Century British Theatre, (2018).
None are known
William Tyldesley, Michael William Balfe: his life and his English operas, (Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing, 2003), pp. 75 - 79, includes a description and analysis of the opera. There are also sections giving some background to the opera in the books on Balfe by Walsh, Kenney and Barrett (see book list).
Frederick Burwick, British Drama of the Industrial Revolution. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015) pp. 240-243, contrasts the approaches of Fitzball and Serle in their respective Joan of Arcs.
|
|