Title header



 

 


The Last Crusade

 Music by Alexander Mitchell

Libretto by Burdett Vyse

New English Opera House (Royalty Theatre), London
November 2, 1850

front

Libretto title page

 

Cast

The cast as listed in the printed libretto

Count Dietrich (Lord of the Castle of Liebenstein)

Count Hugo Elbegast (Rejected Suitor of Armgard)

Heinrich (Heir of Liebenstein)
                                 (Sons of Count Dietrich)
Rudolph (Brother of Heinrich)

Hermann

First Knight

Second Knight

 

Armgard (An Orphan Heiress of Steinberg,
                                 and Ward of Count Dietrich)

Zulieka (A Greek Captive)

- Mr Gilbert

- John Gregg

- Charles Durand
     (Pupil of Mr J. Barnett)
- Bridge Frodsham

- Mr Lawson

- Mr Richards

- Mr Alderson

 

- Mrs Alexander Newton
 

- Susanna Lowe

                                                    Conductor - Mr Anschuez [1]

[1] Bell's  New Weekly Messenger (Nov. 10, 1850). Mitchell conducted the earlier private performances

 

History

The first mention of the opera seemed to have been in early 1846.[1]  It then had a trial performance at the Hanover Square Rooms on October 12, 1846, although it sounds as if the libretto was read out and then the music included as required. It was characterised as "a clumsy and imperfect exposition " but "not deficient in cleverness and dramatic effect".[2]  The opera had not been submitted to the Examiner at that point as it was a private performance. A similar effort, possibly performed as intended with the spoken dialogue, was made at the Music Hall, Bedford Square, on August 16, 1848.[3] The reception was claimed to be enthusiastic. The overture was given by Queen Victoria's private band in Buckingham Palace on February 27, 1849. 

The first public performance of the opera was as Die treuen Bruder in Brunswick, Germany, in 1850, where again it was said to have been successful.  It finally achieved a public performance in London at the New English Opera House on November 2, 1850, but the enterprise closed within a few days. In 1860, Mitchell instigated a number of concerts in which some or all of the vocal and instrumental  music was given in support of the Milton Society for Improving the Social Standing of the Blind, for example, at the Horns Tavern, Kennington, on April 20,1860.[4]

[1] The Observer (Feb. 8, 1846) quoting The Globe

[2] Morning Herald (Oct. 13, 1846)

[3] The Era (Aug. 20, 1848)

[4]  The South London Chronicle (April 28, 1860).

 

Plot

Supposedly based on legends associated with the castle of Liebenstein, the plot concerned two brothers, Count Heinrich and Rudolph, both of whom are secretly in love with Armgard, an heiress and the ward of their father, Count Dietrich. Count Hugo, the evil genius of the opera, had also sets his heart on her, but has been refused. He learns from her that Rudolph is the favoured one and determines that Rudolph shall not have her. He causes confusion all round by having Armgard think a present from Heinrich is actually from Rudolph so having her show her gratitude for it and give Heinrich the idea that he is the favoured one. In his disappointment Rudolph signs up to go off on a crusade under Hugo's command. Heinrich learns of the mistake too late to stop Rudolph so goes off after him on the crusade.

The scene then changes to Palestine, and the assault and burning of Nazareth. Heinrich is captured but is helped to escape by a beautiful Greek slave, Zulieka, who brings him to Rudolph's camp. Heinrich tells Rudolph of Hugo's duplicity but Hugo turns up and arrests Heinrich. He says that he will spare his life on condition that Rudolph will become a Knight Templar. Rudolph agrees to this on condition of a last meeting with Armgard before taking the oath of the order. Armgard, in the meantime, has been surprised at not hearing from Rudolph since his departure. Her ladies tell her that a body of crusaders is approaching, with Rudolph at their head, who details the events which occurred in Palestine and that they must part forever. Heinrich also arrives with Zulieka.

The final scene is set in the Hall of Knight Templars as Rudolph is preparing for his inauguration. Count Hugo exults in the success of his revengeful scheme but, before the ceremony is completed, Heinrich enters, and, in the name of the Emperor, arrests Hugo and abolishes the Knight Templars. The two couples can now finally wed.

 

Reception

There were few reports on the performances, partly because of the unfamiliar venue and its very short life. It is clear that the performance was very poor, none of the singers being experienced opera singers and probably stage direction being minimal; Mitchell, being blind, only able to rehearse the music.

The Illustrated London News (Nov. 9, 1850) did not mince its words reflecting that such a large city as London

with all its musical and vocal resource
could have produced such an exhibition of incompetency and puerility. The only relief to the annoyance caused by the melancholy display, being that it presented itself nearly throughout a three-act opera - "The Last Crusade" by Mr. Mitchell, the blind composer - as a burlesque; and as such was laughed at by those amateurs who could not feel how much injury was done to "native talent" by the disastrous performance; whilst, on the other hand, the "friends" of the establishment, by a series of parodies on great lyric triumphs, in the shape of encores, re-calls. and ovations, were adding fuel to the flame of disgust and discontent. Criticism on Mr. Mitchell's pretensions is utterly disarmed by the glaring deficiency of the execution. For the future foundation, on a permanent basis, of a really National Opera-House, nothing could be more fatal to art and artists than Tuesday's " Last Crusade."

The Era (Nov. 10, 1850) withheld its judgment:
When the Last Crusade was originally represented at the Grand Ducal Theatre, Brunswick, the German critics were loud and almost unanimous in their approval of it as a musical composition; they spoke of the boldness of its conception, melodious phrases, and high dramatic colouring. For the life of us we could not see it on Tuesday. But this probably might have arisen from the defective manner in which self-evident propositions were misrepresented. The merits of some of the songs burst through the barriers which bad singing impaled them in, while two or three of the concerted pieces indicated musical capabilities of no common order. The acting was out of all character, and frequently author and composer were travestied beyond endurance. Some of the choruses were passable, and exhibited traits of careful rehearsing ; but the performance, as a whole, was a dead failure. It would be, therefore, ridiculous to attempt a critical analysis of the real merits of the blind composer until his work is performed so as to give us some definite idea of his meaning. At present we have it not.

The Observer (Nov. 10, 1850) was a little more positive:
The opera being produced on a very limited scale and being sustained by principals who were totally unaccustomed to the stage, anything like a detailed opinion of its effectiveness is impossible. Still the attempt to procure a hearing for the work at a time when no operatic theatre is open, was creditably made, and the scenery and costumes displayed superior taste on the part of the manager. Several of the pieces were encored, and at the end the composer, Mr. Mitchell, was twice called forward with the greatest enthusiasm.

The Weekly Dispatch (Nov. 10, 1850) also tried to be sympathetic to the effort:
We do not feel bound to speak without reserve upon the merits of the vocalists, all of whom were new to the stage, and of course laboured under disadvantages common to debutants. There was much talent displayed; but while we say this we are quite sure that many additions and some omissions of performers must be made before the undertaking can be turned into a profitable speculation to the managers, and become a useful one to the public.

 

Comment

The Weekly Dispatch (Oct. 13, 1850) in welcoming the new company touched on one of the problems

bedevilling English opera:
This theatre has been taken by an operatic commonwealth, for the purpose of bringing out the works of English composers, and of fostering generally native musical talent. In an age in which there is so much exclusiveness practiced, and when an author's or performer's success depends so much upon his being known, this scheme will be found a great boon to many who have not been able to appease managerial dignity, or conquer its prejudices.

On November 10, 1850, the same paper elaborated a further danger that
Singers belong, like poets, to the genus irritabile, and we trust no professional jealousies will mar the success or prejudice  the advancement of "the commonwealth".

 

Scores and Librettos

The manuscript of the libretto passed by the Examiner is in the British Library, Add MS 43030 ff.229-289. It was licenced on October 29, 1850. The printed libretto (London: W.S. Johnson, 1850) is available at the Library of Congress and the HathiTrust. There are few differences between the manuscript and printed librettos.

There do not appear to be any full or vocal scores of either the opera or individual numbers. Unusually the music was published by John Gregg, one of the singers.

 

Recordings

None are known

 

Books, Articles, Online

None are known