Title header



 

 


Frances Susannah Shannon

1792 - 1864

Frances Shannon had a rather colourful life. Born Frances Mongan in Ireland, she was left fatherless as a young girl and her uncle, Terence Warburton, later the Bishop of Cloyne, became her guardian [1]. In 1812, she married the Revd. Thomas Carr, who was attracted by her "peculiarly fascinating manners" and they had, at least, four children. Carr overstretched himself financially when building a house and was committed to the Marshalsea, the debtors' prison in London, in 1818.  While he was there Frances went off to Britain with Charles Shannon, a Dublin barrister and her children. When Carr got out of prison, he went after the couple and took back the children. In 1823 he sued Shannon for "Criminal Conversations", i.e. for eloping with his wife, for which he was awarded £500 [2]. By this time Frances had had a child by Shannon, who had changed his name to Shannon Carr to give the impression that they were married. They went on to have at least 5 children. At some point in the late 1820s, they left for Paris where they lived as Mr and Mrs Shannon. Charles may have had a sister there and perhaps the legal, financial or social pressures of their ambiguous position in England made it politic. Charles died in 1832 in Paris [3]. Probably in 1834[4], Frances and her children returned to live in England but she had great difficulty supporting them despite some modest writing success and had to apply for grants from the Literary Fund (Royal Literary Fund). Around the end of 1839, they went back to France. Later her daughters married and moved to England and she did so too at some point as she was included in the 1851 census and died in Chelsea, London, on March 4, 1864. She is buried in Brompton Cemetery. 

In 1826, Frances, using the name Frances Susanna Carr and adding that she was the niece of the Bishop of Cloyne, published a novel, Genevive, together with a historical sketch about Isabella, Queen of Castile entitled Isabella (see here). Following their move to France, Charles Shannon translated Jean-François-Alfred Bayard′s, Christine ou La Reine de Seize Ans about Queen Christina of Sweden. It was staged at Drury Lane on October 24, 1828  as The Youthful Queen  (see here for an 1857 edition). Charles then worked with Thomas Thackeray on adapting a number of French plays for the English stage, the best known being a "petite comedy" titled My Wife, or My Place that was premiered at the Haymarket on August 20, 1831.  After Charles death, Frances continued to work with Thackeray, although it was not made public. In particular she wrote some or all of the libretto for The Mountain Sylph but Thackeray took the credit.

John Barnett's The Mountain Sylph premiered on August 25, 1834. The librettist then, and often now, was said to be Thomas J. Thackeray. Barnett specifically acknowledged him in the 1834 vocal score but when the score was reissued with revisions by Barnett in 1880 (British Library dating) he omitted any name. Around a year after the premiere, on August 9, 1835, The Satirist wrote the following:

We, in common with others, have at different times awarded high praise to Mr. Thackeray for the manner in which The Mountain Sylph is dramatised; if, however, the communication of a correspondent be correct, the merit is to be attributed to a different source. "Mr Thackeray" says our informant, "never wrote a line of that piece; it was written by Mrs Shannon, a lady residing in Paris. Mr. Thackeray professed to be her friend, and in a friendly way took upon himself the honours of authorship, and sent Mrs Shannon 30l [£], as her share of the profits arising from the piece".  Verily this seems a short and easy mode of acquiring fame; and no wonder Mr. Thackeray soon got admitted as a member of the Dramatic Authors' Society. On a discovery of the affair he was expelled and Mrs. Shannon elected in his stead [5]. We may also state, in justice to Mr. Thackeray, that he has been induced to refund some further portion of his gains, arising from the success of the opera.

The Observer (Mar. 5, 1837), the Theatrical Observer (Mar. 6, 1837) and The Analyst (Dec. 1839), p.494, also made similar statements supporting Frances. When Duncombe later published her play Jealousy, Frances was described as author of The Mountain Sylph.

As well as the Mountain Sylph, Frances in a letter to the Literary fund claimed ownership of other works that Thackeray had passed off as his own. These included a short-lived adaptation of Auber′s Gustave Trois, entitled Gustavus of Sweden, at the Royal Victoria Theatre on November 7, 1833, with the music arranged by Barnett. In the customary practice of the day, the music was actually a mixture of Barnett′s own and Auber′s music. Thus, Barnett had worked with Thackeray before The Mountain Sylph.

In 1835, The Naval and Military Gazette (Aug 8, 1835) credited her with joint authorship with Charles Selby of The Guardian Sylph, a fairy operetta, that premiered at the Queen's Theatre on August 3, 1835, although most sources mentioned just Selby.   However, Frances's participation seems very plausible given that it was closely modelled on The Mountain Sylph.  Given that she had contributed, at least, some of the libretto of The Mountain Sylph, it would be natural for John Barnett to want to  involve her in his next opera, Fair Rosamond (1837).

Barnett's Fair Rosamond premiered on February 2, 1837. The librettist then, and often now, was said to be Barnett's brother Charles Zachary Barnett. The Observer (Mar. 5, 1837) wrote that "We mentioned some months ago that a lady was the author of the words of Mr. Barnett's new opera of Fair Rosamond.  This lady is Mrs Shannon". After mentioning the dispute with Thackeray over the text of The Mountain Sylph, it continued "In the same way it appears that Mrs. Shannon's property in the words of Fair Rosamond is disputed by Mr. Joseph Bennett, the brother of the composer". [It identified the wrong brother, as Charles is always credited and Joseph was a musician rather than playwright]. This looks unlikely as the Barnett's were familiar with Thackeray's previous deception and more like a garbled rumour as the sheet music cited both C.Z Barnett and F. Shannon as the authors when published by Cramer etc. a few weeks later. Thomas Bellamy's 1840 book of Lyric Poetry of Glees, etc.. only named Shannon, so she may well have been responsible for the songs and Charles Barnett for the dialogue.

Even if Shannon was responsible for the initial librettos, changes would be needed to fit with the composer's and the theatre's needs and that this would need to be done in London probably without Frances's presence. This is where Thackeray and Charles Barnett would have been involved.

Frances's final known work was Jealousy, a translation of Bayard and Paul-Aimé Chapelle′s Mathilde ou la Jalousie, first given in Paris in 1835. It was staged at Covent Garden on October 20, 1838. Charles was sometimes named as joint author[6] but he was dead before its Paris premiere. Possibly, his name was added to attract more interest, given that he was better known in theatrical circles.

Why have Frances's claims received so little attention? Partly there was a prejudice against female authors. Sometimes female authors were reluctant to publicly own such work, as reflected in the oblique way Frances Shannon made her claim. Some women found it difficult or were unable (like Frances when she lived in Paris) to be involved in matters like negotiations, rehearsals etc and used a man as a proxy, thus easily giving the impression that the man was the author. In any case authorship rights were very unclear at that time and asserting them difficult. There was a wider problem that drama as a genre was at its lowest ebb and consequently there was little regard as to who wrote plays or librettos. Once an identification had been made, there would have been little interest in re-examining it, either then or later, leaving any wrong attribution to be repeated so adding to its apparent authority.

A more detailed paper developed from a presentation on Shannon's life and career given at the "Music in 19th Century Britain" Conference held at the Open University, Milton Keynes, 28-30 June 2023, can be found here .

[1] WikiTree page for Frances Susanna (Mongan) Carr  - https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Mongan-140 .[Accessed Dec. 23, 2022].

[2] The Times (Jun. 28, 1823). Carr had asked for £6000.

[3] A Charles Shannon is recorded as having died in Paris in 1832. As nothing further was heard of Charles after 1832 and as their last child was born in 1831, it seems almost certain that it was the same man. Mrs Shannon was recorded as living in Paris a year or two after that (The Satirist, Aug. 8, 1835)

[4] The Morning Post (Sept. 22, 1834) recorded that a "Mrs Shannon" had landed from France.

[5] Leman Thomas Rede, The Road to the Stage. (London: J. Onwhyn, 1836), p. 71 recorded Thackeray as being a member of the Society and has no mention of Shannon. Thackeray might have been reinstated in the meantime. Shannon was credited with being an honorary member in the Duncombe edition of Jealousy. As a woman, honorary membership was all she could achieve. If Thackeray's deception is correct that it was somewhat ironic in that Thackeray was a leading light in the campaign for fairer payments for authors.

[6] The manuscript sent to the Lord Chamberlain is anonymous but the index to that volume of plays in the British Library  (Add MS 42948) has  both names.