Title header



 

 


Shaw, Mrs Alfred - Mary Postans

1814-1876

Shaw was a very highly regarded contralto even though she had a comparatively short career. She studied at the Royal Academy of Music and then in Italy. In 1838, Mendelssohn invited her to sing in Germany after which, in 1839, she again went to Italy and La Scala, Milan, where she performed in Verdi's first opera, Oberto. Up to that point she had concentrated on concerts and oratorio [1] and her stage career lasted only about five years. Much of this was spent in Italy or singing Italian opera in English back in England. The only English opera she performed in was Benedict's The Brides of Venice at Drury Lane that premiered on April 22, 1844 [2]. One of its songs, "By the sad sea waves", became widely associated with her. She did not sing in its October 1844 revival and had reverted to concerts.

Her prominence at that time can be seen in the playbill below for Edward Fitzball's benefit on May 28, 1844, that included the first act of The Brides of Venice. Her name has clear precedence over the other singers including two of the best known English singers of the  day, Emma Romer and William Harrison.

In 1843, she  had begun to suffer vocal problems, which some have seen as stemming from the death of her infant son and

pici

National Trust Images

pic

Illustrated London News (Apr. 27, 1844)

her husband being declared insane.  By the last half of  1846,  she was drastically curtailing her appearances supposedly due to her increasing number of private engagements (Observer, June 7, 1846) but more likely because her vocal problems had become too severe. By March, 1847, she was said to have retired (Pictorial Times, Mar 27, 1847). However, she did make occasional appearances at low profile concerts until at least 1850.  She also taught.

Mrs. Cornwall (Margaret) Baron Wilson, Our Actresses. Volume 2 (London: Smith, Elder & Co., 1844), pp. 235-238, has, on her own admission, little to say about her career but characterises her voice as "not of very great compass, but is most flexible, melodious, and rich in tone; and she has acquired the highest degree of musical expression".  She extolls her "amiable and honourable character"  and her "steady perseverance in the path of rectitude" in the face of "many afflicting domestic circumstances". Finally, she praises her for sticking with her English name rather than "appending a Signora or Madame".

There are several more modern accounts. Kurt Gänzl, Victorian Vocalists,  (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 2017), pp. 615-621, has a chapter on her and there is a web page at https://momh.org.uk/exhibitions/mrs-alfred-shaw-1814-1876/.

Matildie Wium, "Reporting on the Tribulations of Mary Shaw", in Christine Fuhrmann and Alison Mero, Opera and British Print Culture in the Long Nineteenth Century. (Clemson: Clemson University Press, 2023), pp. 87-103,  has a short biography as well as discussing how the press handled her career and how it fitted into wider cultural concerns and ideas of the time.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

[1] She sang in the British premiere of Mendelssohn's St Paul in Liverpool on October 3, 1836.

[2] She was said to have sung in Balfe's The Siege of Rochelle for his benefit night at the Princess's on July 1, 1843 (Ganzl, p. 620). The benefit had been scheduled for June 26,  but Balfe had a bad bout of influenza (Morning Post, June 26, 1843)  and so the benefit was moved to July 1 (Morning Herald, June 30, 1843) . In fact, Shaw was advertised as singing in the concert that followed the opera but not in the opera itself.

pic

Edward Fitzball's benefit, May 28, 1844

British Library Playbills