Title header



 

 


Henry Haigh and
Elizabeth Haigh-Dyer

 

Haigh, Henry (1830-1904)

Haigh was born in Yorkshire on August 1, 1830. He was the son of a shoemaker but both he and his older brother, Edwin, became musicians, suggesting musical interest and ability in the family. The first mention of him seems to be at a concert in Hull on January 29, 1850 with Edwin as pianist [1]. A few months later, at another concert he was billed as a pupil of Signor Furtado [2]. At a concert on January 16, 1851 he was described as "from the London Concerts", so had apparently appeared in the capital by then. In April 1851 he was one of the "immense phalanx of operatic talent" at the Surrey Theatre in London. Louisa Pyne, William Harrison and Charles Manvers, artists with whom he would later work, were also on the bill [3].  By March 1852, again at a concert organised by Edwin, he was listed as from the Theatre Royal, Edinburgh. In the November, he  made his debut in Glasgow, where he was praised for "combining a fine quality of voice, with great good taste" and suggesting that he "may take his place among the best English operatic singers" [4].

image

In late 1852, he moved to Dublin where he sang in opera, oratorio and concerts until March 1855 when he returned for engagements in Bath and Bristol. While in Dublin at the Theatre Royal, he sang in the premiere of Lanza's Hamet and Zelena on February 1, 1855. He then seems to have disappeared from view after April until the end of the year and it is probable that this was when he went to Italy for more training [5]. In February 1856, he made his first appearance at Covent Garden along with Lucy Escott in Balfe's The Bohemian Girl. The Standard (Feb. 19, 1856) wrote that his "style of singing betrays cultivation, though there is apparently very little stage experience". The following month he joined James Tully and Frederick Kingsbury's company at Drury Lane. Elizabeth Dyer was one of the company and on April 25, 1857 they married while in Hull on tour with the company, of which Haigh had become a part manager [6]. The tour included a season at  the Surrey Theatre in London.  Near the end of 1857, the company broke up following Lucy Escott's defection. The Haighs made an appearance in Edinburgh at the end of the year and in several other cities early in 1858. They seem to have sung scenes from operas, presumably with piano, and, at least sometimes, supported by members of the local stock company [7].  During Lent both appeared in "monster concerts" at the Alhambra in London. In April they joined Tully's new company at Sadler's Wells and stayed with him on his company's tour in the latter half of the year, although fitting in some concerts along the way. Some of 1859 was spent touring with Frederick Kingsbury as conductor and, in the autumn, he joined the Pyne-Harrison company at Covent Garden, but not his wife. Unfortunately, William Harrison took almost all the leading tenor roles in new English operas, of which there were 13 during the company's existence, while Haigh only sung in the premieres of Alfred Mellon's Victorine (1860) and Julius Benedict's The Lily of Killarney (1862). After the season, over Easter 1860, he  and his wife were part of a short run of Wallace's Maritana at Drury Lane organised by Dr James Pech. The Observer (Apr. 15, 1860) wrote that "He has a small sweet tenor voice, sings with taste and delicacy, and, in a very limited range of parts, is a useful performer". Both then sang with his National English Opera Company [8] as well as in a few concerts before he returned to the Pyne-Harrison company for the 1860-1861 season. A provincial concert tour with his wife followed until Pyne and Harrison's 1861-1862 season, his last with them at Covent Garden. After its conclusion he set up his own company for a provincial tour.

In September 1862, Haigh petitioned for bankruptcy owing just under £900. He blamed his position  on "insufficient receipts as manager of the New English Opera Company and being unable to procure an engagement" [9]. He was not hired for the 1862-1863 season by the Pyne-Harrison company, to whom, in any case, he owed money. He did sing in opera at Sadlers Wells, in his own company and in Corri's company, had a spot singing  in a Scottish confection entitled Bonnie Dundee at Drury Lane and sang in concerts and oratorio. However, his oratorio singing was not admired. Commenting on his performance in Mendelssohn's Elijah for the Sacred Harmonic Society, the Englishwoman's Domestic Magazine (Vol. VI, Mar.,1863, p. 234) was not alone in its opinion that "He is gifted with a charming voice, but his inertness or incapacity render him utterly incapable of any dramatic intensity - of musician-like reading of the intention of the author"[10]. His operatic singing also drew criticism from the Bradford Observer (Oct. 15, 1863): "Mr Henry Haigh's voice was once a fine tenor and would be still if he were not so fond of using the falsetto". Towards the end of 1863 the Haighs advertised their annual visit to Scotland.

Haigh again joined the Pyne-Harrison company when it went on tour in Spring 1864 as well as a spell with Henry Corri's company. He was hired by the Royal English Opera (Limited), who took over from Pyne-Harrison at Covent Garden for the 1864-1865 season and went on tour with them afterwards. He appeared in the premiere of George Alexander Macfarren's Helvellyn for them. When the company folded in February 1866, he joined E.T. Smith's production of Weber's Der Freischutz at Astley's and then toured with Thirlwall and Corri's Grand English Opera Company. In early 1867, he went on a concert tour of Scotland. The Aberdeen Press and Journal (Feb. 20, 1867) commented that he "disappointed not a little those who on former occasions have heard him sing. His soft tones seemed to have lost in sweetness; and his best efforts were more or less marred by carelessness or unevenness of voice".   Later that year he toured with Edmund Rosenthal's Grand English Opera Company with the Alessandri sisters as the leading ladies. The tour included Hull at the end of August when they were followed the next week by Loveday and Summers' Grand English Opera Company with Haigh's wife, Elizabeth  Haigh-Dyer, as its prima donna.  By the end of the year, he had also joined Loveday and Summers with whom he toured until April 1869.

In August 1869 he sailed, without his wife, for America having been recruited on a seven month contract with the Caroline Richings Opera Company. His reception in the US was mixed. Preston [11] claimed that he was an "utter failure" but The Era (Oct. 24, 1869) wrote that he was "well received" and "rapturously encored" at least on one occasion. However, given he was back with Loveday's Company in Britain by January 1870 well ahead of his contract's termination, it would seem that he was sacked [12].  However short it may have been, he and Loveday made the most of it advertising Haigh as "the greatest English Tenor on the British Operatic Stage" and that it was "his first appearance since his Successful Tour through the United States"[13]. Later that year he again started up his own opera company with his wife as prima donna and including her sister Teresa Greenaway. At that point he had "an industrious and efficient orchestra"[14], conductor George Cooke.  The tour ran through until the start of 1872.

In 1872, Haigh joined a company run by Cooke and Addison but by the July was advertising his services. In the autumn he stood in for an indisposed Sims Reeves for several concerts in Glasgow and appeared in opera bouffe at the Alhambra. More concerts and an engagement with the Grand Duchess Opera Bouffe company followed until August 1873. In Liverpool his performance in Offenbach's The Grand Duchess of Gerolstein was compared to that of William Harrison and found wanting, "while his acting reminded one of the true Harrison style, there were wanting the  the necessary vigour and power in his vocalisation"[15]. He and his wife then did a number of costumed concert performances of operas with piano but without a chorus, entitled English Opera Recitals. They then joined Miss Carry Nelson's Comic Opera Company in the autumn of 1873 but by early 1874 he was again advertising his services. He cannot have had much luck for they went back to touring with their English Opera Recitals company and possibly with a more complete company (see here).  The Haighs also seem to have been hired for particular theatre's productions, such as Rob Roy at the Theatre Royal, Liverpool, in March 1874.

He continued to tour until the spring of 1876; his wife had advertised in The Era (Jan. 23, 1876) that she would be disengaged at Easter so they must have planned to wrap up the company around then. However, things did not go smoothly and Elizabeth was ill for much of the first three months so that other prima donnas, mainly Jessie Mills, had to be hired. Elizabeth was back by April but in early May both were advertising that they were disengaged [16]. Their final date had been at Grantham where they were "comparatively unsupported" [17]. Perhaps this or just lack of funds convinced them that there was no future in touring as The Era (Nov. 5, 1876) carried a notice that the things left by Mr Henry Haigh in Grantham would, if not claimed, be sold to defray expenses and, as presumably he did not do so, The Era (Dec 6, 1876) advertised the sale of his theatrical wardrobe.  Concerts again followed as well as a short engagement with Telma and Walsham's opera company but by December 1877, he was again "at liberty". He and his wife then advertised for students before he again tried touring in the autumn of 1878 with The London Drawing Room Opera Company, no doubt a similar pared down effort to the Recitals company, but it lasted only until early 1879. There do not appear to be any further appearances by him [18] but he was fortunate enough to be one of the few remaining recipients of the Covent Garden Fund, receiving £55 a quarter [19].

The Morning Post (Apr. 10, 1860) in its review of Maritana at Drury Lane, perceptively wrote that

Mr Haigh has a beautiful voice, and much natural taste, and, with careful study, might become an ornament to our lyric stage; but he has still much, very much, to learn. His tone wants development. his style lacks breadth, his phrasing symmetry and distinctness.  Thought and earnestness of purpose, too, are wanting, and thus his performances, despite the charms which very uncommon physical gifts impart to them, generally leave an unsatisfactory impression. We feel in listening to him that a man is before us who might accomplish a great deal... but who disappoints us by a seeming indifference and apparently unconscious  displays of histrionic, no less than musical, ignorance. If in the midst of these shortcomings we did not catch some occasional glimpses of a better nature ... we should not expend so many words on Mr Haigh, or consider his powers so attentively; but although he has shown us little as yet beyond which nature has done for him, she has been so bountiful, and he is so youthful, that bright hopes may reasonably be entertained with respect to his future career. But he must think, and feel, and study, and reflect a great deal before he can accomplish all that we believe him to be capable of achieving.

Haigh never seemed to find that dedication and sense of purpose to achieve all that his peers thought him capable of. On the other hand, the same article contrasted him with his his wife who " has not such physical means, but [who], nevertheless, is a better singer and actress".

 

[1] The Hull Packet (Jan. 18, 1850)

[2] The Hull Packet (Dec. 20, 1850). This was when he sang at another concert organised by Edwin in early 1851. His teacher was named as Furtadi but this must be a misspelling of Furtado, who was an active teacher at that time.

[3] The Era (Apr.13, 1851)

[4] The Hull Packet (Oct. 29, 1852) quoting a Glasgow newspaper. They obviously took an interest in his progress as a local boy.

[5] T. Allston Brown, History of the American Stage. (New York: Dick & Fitzgerald, 1870), p.154, wrote that after 1852 Haigh spent the next three years in Dublin followed by a further two in Italy, including at La Scala. This is not correct as he was back in London by 1856, but it may be a garbled version of what happened except that both stays were rather shorter than Brown claimed. The Morning Post (Aug. 5, 1863) listed an Italian address amongst others in his bankruptcy discharge.

[6]  Sunday Times ( Sep. 28, 1862). His bankruptcy proceedings, Escott, Haigh and Durand also appear to have been joint managers.

[7] Belfast Mercury (Mar. 2, 1858)

[8] The Cheltenham Looker-on (May 5, 1860) described it as Mr Haigh's Opera Company.

[9] Sunday Times ( Sep. 28, 1862).

[10] At a Sacred Harmonic Society Concert of Handel's Messiah the previous year, Haigh had been paid £8-8s (London Daily News, Dec. 18, 1886)

[11] Katherine Preston, Opera for the People  ( New York : Oxford University Press, 2017), p.127.

[12] Katherine Preston, Op.Cit., p.137.

[13] Norwich Mercury (Apr. 16, 1870)

[14] Western Mail (Nov. 29, 1870)

[15] Liverpool Mercury (Jun. 24, 1873)

[16] The Era (May 3, 1876)

[17] The Era (Apr. 30, 1876). However, the Lincolnshire Chronicle (Apr. 28, 1876) reckoned that attendance had been "pretty good".

[18] There was a Mr H Haigh who sang mainly around Yorkshire in the 1880s and was based in Huddersfield .

[19] Glasgow Herald (Nov. 13, 1899) . The income from the fund might well have been their main income as the 1881 census did not show the Haigh's having any servants. The 1901 census showed Haigh living in a boarding house in Rhyl, where or close to where he died.

 

Haigh-Dyer, Madame - Elizabeth Mary Dyer (1834-1899)
At a case before the Insolvent Debtor's court in 1857 [1] Dyer was said to have been articled to Frederick Kingsbury for singing tuition for 3 years from August 1853 and including her board and lodging. He had also promoted her appearance at Drury Lane and for all this, he was entitled to half her income. However, she had broken the agreement and sung elsewhere without sharing the proceeds.  He was out of pocket as a result and demanding recompense. She claimed that he had not taught her piano and harmony and that she was owed money as a result of his insolvency. The case was adjourned  to give them time to settle, which eventually they did by February 1859 [2].

Her first public appearance seems to have been at a New Philharmonic Society concert on February 14, 1855.  Her first appearance at Drury Lane was on July 28, 1855 in Weber's Der Freischutz. She was said to have made "a very successful and promising debut [3] and that her "agreeable voice and neatness of style proclaim her an acquisition to the company" [4].  From then until autumn 1859 she usually performed in companies along with Henry Haigh, whom she married in 1857.  He joined the Pyne-Harrison company's 1859-1860 season at Covent Garden while she went to sing at the Royal Pavilion Theatre along with William Parkinson and Edmund Rosenthal. She joined her husband for a brief engagement singing in Wallace's Maritana at Drury Lane over Easter 1860 at the end of the 1859-1860 season. The Daily News (Apr. 10, 1860) wrote that:

Her action was easy and intelligent, with considerable sprightliness. Her voice was flexible, but her intonation, especially in high notes, was uncertain, and the florid passages with which the music abounds were beyond her powers of articulate execution.

Several months with her husband's National English Opera Company followed before he returned to the Pyne-Harrison company for their 1860-1861 season. For Elizabeth, the final months of 1860 and much of 1861 proved largely empty except for a few concerts. In October 1861 she advertised in the Era (Oct. 13, 1861) that she could "accept engagements for Opera, Concerts and Oratorios". In the spring and autumn of 1862, she sang with Hamilton Braham's Grand English Opera company and in between with her husband's opera company and in concerts with her husband. In June 1863 she, but not her husband, joined Brookhouse Bowler's English Opera Company as primadonna for a short tour until mid August. At the end of August she became primadonna of Rosenthal's company but with a break over the Christmas period when she and Henry were engaged for a show at the New Theatre Royal, Glasgow. By now she was usually titled Madame Haigh-Dyer [5].

She stayed with Rosenthal until the summer of 1864 but then after a brief engagement in a company put together by Oliver Summers, she joined George Loveday's company where she stayed until 1870. She did have a brief break in March 1866, when she went to Italy for about a month for more training. Her forthcoming appearance with her husband at Astley's for E.T.Smith's production of Der Freischutz was noted by The Times (Mar. 20, 1866) as her first London appearance since her return from Milan and the Sunday Times (Apr. 8, 1866) review wrote that:

Since her absence from England her voice has much improved, and her intonation is far more perfect; she, however, does not succeed in rapid transitions - not so much owing to want of power or insufficient compass, as to inexpertness in hitting the required note with that mastery and self-command which results from the combined excellence and high state of cultivation both of the ear and method of producing sound. Every other attribute she possesses: a fine person, with countenance prepossessing, and attitudes graceful and commanding". 

In October 1870, her husband again set up his own company which ran through until spring 1872 [6], when they appeared as the stars of a production at the Theatre Royal, Leeds. Spring and summer of 1872, she was with Rose Hersee's Company, in the autumn at the National Standard theatre as part of Aynsley Cooke's English Opera Company and ended up in the November in some concerts in Glasgow. For much of 1873 she and her husband toured their English Opera Recital Company, essentially concert performances in costume with piano but without a chorus. She sang in pantomime in Leeds and York in early 1874 and she and her husband played in musical dramas, such as Rob Roy in York until May. In June 1874 they resurrected their recitals company and toured through 1875.  Although ill for the first three months of 1876, she returned to the company in the April but by the end of the month the company had folded. She and her husband sang in concerts for the rest of 1876 but by early 1877 she was appearing with the Telma and Walsham's Company. The Preston Chronicle (Mar. 3, 1877) confessed that "we have heard her to greater advantage but whatever casual deficiency we may complain of in voice she fully atones for by her ever natural, and, when required, majestic histrionic abilities".

The Hampshire Telegraph (Sep. 19, 1877) noted  "Since her last appearance here she has adopted contralto in place of soprano parts, and it will be understood by this that her voice will not now bear the strain to which it has long been exposed". She was probably by nature a contralto or mezzo and sang as that in several companies but probably forced up so that she could take more lucrative soprano roles and save the cost of a soprano for their own opera company. In view of the wide range of roles that she took, often with more than one in a week,  it was hardly surprising that her voice suffered. They included opera bouffe, lead English opera roles, Amina in Bellini's La sonnambula, Bellini's Norma, Donizetti's Lucia,  Leonora in Verdi's Il Trovatore and Leonora in Beethoven's Fidelio.

She sang with Telma and Walsham until, at least,  April 1878.  Perhaps no engagements were forthcoming for by the summer she and her husband were advertising singing lessons and preparing people for the "lyric stage". She and her husband then did a tour until spring 1879 with what they titled The London Drawing Room Opera Company but which was also titled Madame Haigh-Dyer's English Opera company when it appeared in Walsall [7]. It was probably a pared down operation similar to the earlier Opera Recitals company. Although Haigh-Dyer advertised that she was free she never seemed to have had anything more than an occasional concert from then on. In 1880 and 1883, she sang in charity concerts for the local Roman Catholic church at Liscard in Cheshire where they had gone to live and where she was also the church organist.  In 1890 she was still teaching, "three guineas a term payable in advance" [8].

 

[1] The Times (Nov. 12, 1857), Teesdale Mercury (Dec. 16, 1857). The case was complicated by the fact that she had married Haigh since the start of the action and, as a married woman, was deemed to be without separate property.

[2] Daily News (Feb 2, 1859)

[3] Sun (July 30, 1855)

[4] Field (Aug. 4, 1855)

[5] Married women calling themselves "Madame" had become the usual way to title themselves by the 1860s rather than "Mrs". Some retained "Miss". A short article, "What's in a title"  gives a brief history of the changes in women's titles  in the 19th century. Haigh-Dyer is interesting in that she swapped the normal order of the husband's name coming second.  Prior to that she was often listed as "Miss Dyer" so she was clearly keen to ensure the prominence of the name.

[6] Towards the end of that time, The Era (Jan.14, 1872) described the company that included Haigh and his wife as being under the management of Mr Grantham. Grantham had been a member of Haigh's company. Either the correspondent made a mistake or, for some reason, there was a switch in management around the end of 1871. Certainly there were a few changes of personnel, Haigh-Dyer's sister Teresa Greenway no longer being a member.

[7] The Era (Dec. 8, 1878). An article in the Dudley and District News (Oct 29, 1881) referred to a visit by Madame Haigh-Dyer's Opera Company but does not say when that was. As mentioned on the Companies page, there were other mentions of a Haigh-Dyer company but to what extent these were references to Henry Haigh's companies and to what extent they were independent of them is unclear. 

[8] Liverpool Mercury (Jan 15, 1890)


                                                                      *********


There was a Miss Dyer who was active from the late 1820s to the late 1840s but she was primarily an actress.