Title header



 

 


"O Vision Entrancing"

 

A British Opera Study Day sponsored by CHOMBEC
 at the University of Bristol, June 12th, 2010.

Russell Burdekin, July 4th, 2010

Steven Martin from Bristol University's CHOMBEC (Centre for the History of Music in Britain, the Empire and Commonwealth) programmed an entertaining and informative day, much of it covering less familiar aspects of opera in Britain from the Victorian era through to the 1950's. CHOMBEC has since been disbanded.

Dr. George Biddlecombe's paper on "Femininity, culture and commerce" looked at how the private and public images of women were reconciled at a time when female soloists were coming into much greater prominence.  In particular, the theatre's somewhat tarnished moral reputation needed to be dispelled in favour of the public's expectation of female virtue and the gulf between the singers" entirely different and expensive lifestyles needed to be bridged to the domesticity familiar to their audiences.  Dr. Biddlecombe touched upon several ways in which this was done, both by the singers and by the music industry.  One particularly interesting point was how the images of Jenny Lind on song and aria scores were fashioned to meet the accepted images of female beauty and only loosely resembled what she actually looked like.  Such ideal images also reflected the Victorian idea that exterior appearances mirrored internal character, reinforced in Lind's case by the many stories of her charitable work and religious beliefs.  A little later, some Patti song scores were published with her sitting at an upright piano in a domestic pose unlikely to have been seen in reality at her castle.  Later discussion pointed out that Clara Butt's publicity almost always featured her family.  It was rather sobering to see that "spin" and "image" go back a long way.

Dr. Valerie Langfield described the difficulties when creating an orchestral score and band parts for use in performances and recordings by Victorian Opera Northwest, RTÉ and others of 19th century operas.  It often required marrying together incomplete scores from different sources, some often revised for new venues, with gaps occasionally having to be filled by an expansion from the vocal score, normally the only score to be published.  Balfe was a particular problem as he was lazy and sketchy in his scores, e.g. which notes to double.  He obviously relied on players being used to his approach and, in any case, always supervised the first performances.  Dr. Langfield played a few excerpts from Balfe's Falstaff, Wallace's Lurline and Macfarren's Robin Hood. 

John Ward spoke on the Carl Rosa company.  Unfortunately, although the archives contain a considerable quantity of music they include little on the company's administration, particularly during Rosa's time.  However, they do include some of the singer Charles Santley's contracts showing that he was earning roughly the equivalent of £10,000 a week for four performances, although he had to provide his own costumes.  Under Rosa's management from 1873 until 1889, the company gave 3,700 performances of 72 operas, the most popular being Balfe's The Bohemian Girl followed by Carmen and including Wagner but not Rossini.  John interspersed his talk with many old photographs from the archive.

After the successful premiere of Elgar's dramatic cantata Caractacus, several people suggested that he turn it into an opera and, seemingly, Elgar did consider it but never seriously attempted it.  Professor Julian Rushton kept everyone wide awake after lunch with his ideas on how that might have been done and possible ways in which certain scenes could have been expanded.  However, he concluded that it would have been difficult to fashion a credible dramatic ending given that the music of the epilogue is the culmination of Elgar's musical scheme with its final appearance of the "Britain" motive confirming the Arch Druid's prophecy of the British Empire, which essentially stands apart from the main action.

Professor John Pickard then took us through a quick tour of Havergal Brian's The Tigers, which he described as a burlesque opera, parts of which reminded him strongly of a Monty Python sketch.  The first of Brian's five completed operas, including a Faust and a Turandot,  it lasts nearly three hours without intervals and has 49 solo parts and a lorry load of assorted percussion so conforming to the picture of Brian's music being larger than life.  Brian composed it following a short spell in army training at the start of the First World War that left him with a very jaundiced attitude to ideas of service and heroism seeing instead only selfishness and incompetence.  The Tigers is the name of a supposedly famous fighting regiment but they are really only interested in shirking and chasing women and when brought to battle run away.  Policemen also get pretty short shrift.  The main relationship within a series of chaotic scenes, one of which is interrupted by a man on an elephant, is between their commander Sir John Stout and Mrs Pamela Freebody.  These are the only two characters to be drawn in any depth and provide a moral of sorts that free love is much to be preferred to war or an unhappy marriage, Brian having left his wife and five children to run off with the maid with whom he later fathered a further five.  Surprisingly, the whole work was performed and recorded in 1983 by the BBC but the recording is not available at present.  Extracts from that performance pointed to an inventive and humorous score in keeping with the madcap action.  However, this obviously cries out for a staged performance, of which, unfortunately, there is no sign.  See http://www.havergalbrian.org/thetigers.htm for more details on the opera.

Dr. Sophie Fuller spoke on " 'Lady-composers of opera' at the turn of the twentieth century".  She listed 12 who persevered with opera at a time when critical opinion held that women should stick to songs.  Of the 12, I must confess I'd only heard of Ethel Smyth and Maud White.  Dr Fuller mainly concentrated on five of these.  Francis Allitsen and Liza Lehmann, were well known for their songs and Lehmann's musical comedy Sergeant Brue (1904) notched up 290 performances.  However, neither of them had much success with their more serious works.  White seems to have lacked the confidence to complete her only opera Smaranda  but Adela  Morrison had success with Der Talisman in 1910, although like Ethel  Smyth, she had to go to Germany to find it.  Dr. Fuller thought it interesting that female composers seemed less keen on killing off their heroines than male composers and seemed to favour lower voices against the more usual high pitched female voices.

Dr Lewis Foreman wrapped up the day with an entertaining account of opera during the post war Festival of Britain which he subtitled "A Good Old Fashioned British Administrative Cock-up!".  There were three specially commissioned operas for the Festival: Britten's Billy Budd, Vaughan Williams' The Pilgrim's Progress and George Lloyd's John Socman, the last of which seems to have caused considerable acrimony between composer and performers.  However, the newly created Arts Council also decided to hold a competition for new operas, fairness being achieved through composers entering under pseudonyms.  After a rather tortuous process, they arrived at three winners:- Arthur Benjamin's A Tale of Two Cities, Berthold Goldschmidt's Beatrice Cenci and Karl Rankl's Deirdre of the Sorrows.  To their embarrassment the Arts Council realised that there were no native British winners in what was supposed to be a Festival of Britain event and hastily added a fourth winner, who, to their chagrin, turned out to be Alan Bush, a well known communist sympathiser with his opera Wat Tyler.  By this time, the schedules had spread into 1951 and with the fall of the Labour government in that year, the whole project was shelved and none of the prize winning entries received a performance.  Bush's was later performed several times in Eastern Europe and Benjamin's and Goldschmidt's had BBC performances but only excerpts of Rankl's have ever been given.  Oddly enough, some of the losing operas, such as Peter Tranchell's The Mayor of Casterbridge, were performed during the Festival.  Dr Foreman read out some of the adjudicators" comments, such as Lennox Berkeley's Nelson being dismissed on grounds of excessive modernism, as well as playing short excerpts from several of the operas mentioned.